News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Your own company? You can do it by jacquesm on Friday March 04, 2011 @04:09PM (#2289806)
The temptation of seeing this depressing bullshit upvoted is too much to resist.

> You know what - actually the story does not make me feel like I can do it. It makes me feel like he's probably hundreds of time cleverer than me.

I'm not, it was just hard work. Lots of it. I suck at math and plenty of other subjects that would come in quite handy as a programmer, probably I'm very much unsuited to the job based on my 'talents'. It's all about persistence.

> He was handrolling assembler as a teen - back then I was doing VB6.

When I was a teen VB6 didn't exist for another decade or more, and assemblers were too expensive but an opcode list could be had as a 'datasheet' for free from the local electronics store.

> All these programmer stories about how they developed OS kernels in x86 MMX extensions when they were 4 years old on Sinclair machines while skipping 4 grades and making hundreds selling lemonade never make me feel like I could do the same.

Such stories do not exist.

> They just make me feel like those guys will always be ahead of me - they started so much earlier.

Yes, just like all those hardworking kids that started even later only to go to even bigger successes.

> I want to hear about the talentless hack who used VB6 to clone some popular software and convinced a big company to purchase it for a few hundreds of thousands after he spent most of his teen years reading science fiction and watching movies. That would make me feel like I could do it.

Why would you like to hear about that? Maybe this article wasn't for you? It is targeted specifically at people currently stuck in jobs held back by peer pressure wondering if they have what it takes to work for themselves and to pursue their own goals in life even if they're not born in to wealth or have a natural talent for 'X', whatever 'X' is.

Way to go to take a positive thing and to try to twist it around into a negative and a depressing thing.

Really, stop being a negative influence and try to see that talent is in large part offset by dedication and time put in. If you want to succeed at something, anything, that does not require some kind of genetic component then go and pursue it relentlessly and be excellent, or at least as good as you can do it, whatever it is.

And with that I will sink back in to retirement, congratulations to those that bet with me that I would get sucked back in, be assured this is a one time affair but I did not want to see Max undo my work.

Re:Your own company? You can do it by zasz on Friday March 04, 2011 @08:07PM (#2290480)
Oh, come ON. You wrote this essay specifically to be encouraging. Somebody responded saying they felt discouraged. You failed, and you're getting feedback. You have something to fix if you want to encourage people. Stop being so defensive.
Re:Your own company? You can do it by jtheory on Sunday March 06, 2011 @07:04PM (#2295448)
To tag on some constructive criticism: a "you can do it too" kind of post needs to emphasize the limitations of your abilities, so that readers can identify with the before-success version of you, and then show the steps to what you accomplished as simply as possible, so they can realistically imagine themselves becoming the after-success version.

If you emphasize how people's jaws dropped when you did X or Y, then only other programmers who feel confident they can do the same will be nodding along (i.e., not most of them).

If you emphasize the limits of what you had figured out, show clearly how you learned how to do X or Y (and how it's not nearly as complicated as it seems), and puncture the illusion of genius as much as possible (it's mostly just persistence), you can give "normal" developers the chance to imagine themselves making jaws drop simply by putting in some time to learn something most people don't know.

Just my, er, 8 cents; I hope this is of some use.

Re:Your own company? You can do it by zasz on Monday March 07, 2011 @04:29AM (#2296592)
I agree. Another poster wrote that assembler was actually straightforward--just very tedious. That would have been a great way for Jacques to make his achievements seem more possible.
Re:Your own company? You can do it by xiaoma on Saturday March 05, 2011 @06:07AM (#2291295)
>Really, stop being a negative influence and try to see that talent is in large part offset by dedication and time put in. If you want to succeed at something, anything, that does not require some kind of genetic component then go and pursue it relentlessly and be excellent, or at least as good as you can do it, whatever it is.

I know this is an unpopular sentiment on this site, but the problem is that everything has at least some genetic component. In the extreme case, rats share about 95% of their DNA with humans but are incapable of doing any of our jobs or even living a decade. Even amongst humans, large differences exist: short people can never become NBA centers, 200cm people can never be great gymnasts, someone with Down's syndrome isn't going to make it as a physicist.

One heart breaking example I witnessed personally was a family member. He wanted more than anything to be a classical musician. From the age of four, he was taught by the same teacher who trained a very successful NY Philharmonic pianist (opera coach). He practiced many hours a day all through his school years and earned both undergraduate and graduate degrees in clarinet performance. By any objective measure he was a very good clarinetist. But he wasn't good enough to make a real living at it. Unlike his mother, who had perfect pitch by the end of grade school, he never developed it. He saw more than one talented peer surpass him in despite his extreme work ethic. In the end, after putting over 25 years of his life and his passion into it, he finally gave up on his dream and became a programmer. Unlike his experiences in music, he very quickly rose to the top of development groups and it was he who was the one surpassing others who had been working at it longer and harder.

Talent matters. There probably haven't been any specific genes linked with business ability as there have been with musical or leaping abilities, but it would be naive to assume that everyone can win if only they sacrifice enough. In many marginal cases, I'm sure effort would make the difference. In other cases, it would just be robbing oneself of valuable time that could be better spent on another pursuit.

Re:Your own company? You can do it by jtheory on Sunday March 06, 2011 @08:20PM (#2295606)
I always push back against this argument, because the general view is that "innate abilities" matter far, far more than they actually do, and this is the reason for many lost opportunities. Woe to the "smart" kid who quickly learns to avoid anything that isn't easy on the first try.

The examples that people give tend to be things like professional athletes and classical musicians, for the simple reason that these kinds of professions are exceptions that are dramatically different from just about anything else you can do with your life.

The reasons why professional athletes are exceptions are more obvious (how many kids want to be pro athletes vs. how many pro athletes does the world need?), so let's look at the professional classical musician.

How many clarinetists are there in the world that make a good living at it? If we rule out the ones making a fairly poor living teaching privately or in high schools, universities, conservatories, etc. (and I'm guessing your family member didn't want to go this route), it's an extremely small, extraordinarily competitive pool, and you need to be at the top of the game to get any chair at all in a good orchestra (and the "winners" may stay in the orchestra for many decades, so orchestras don't hire often...). You are competing against people who have all been in training since age 4, so whatever small influence genes have looms large... and like with pro athletes, there are certainly genetic factors -- musical performance relies very much on extremely fine control of your body, and the shape of your lips, natural size of your chest cavity, etc. etc. will also make some subtle difference beyond what you can achieve with training.

But now let's look at almost any other way to use your life. Almost everything I can think of is a completely different story. Look at what happened to your family member when he left the "pro classical musician" path and went into something else. He knew how to work hard, and he succeeded. I'll bet you he could choose some other field and also succeed.

It's telling that when I meet talented developers, I'm not tempted to hire someone to break their limbs (cf Tonya Harding). I want them to train others, and work with me. With programming (like with most jobs that are not reserved for a few elites in the world), most people currently doing it have done just enough work to be competent (or at least appear competent...), and anyone willing to put in some actual effort can do great things.

And what's even better is that if more people put in some actual effort, the result is that more great things get done, more cool businesses get started (and some actually succeed), and the world is a better place.

There's no end to problems in the world. Any job that's related to solving problems works this way (as opposed to jobs that serve as simple entertainment for the masses, a set of needs that can be met be comparatively few people).

Re:Your own company? You can do it by notahacker on Friday March 04, 2011 @05:18PM (#2290045)
Good to see you back :-p

Seriously, the "depressing" message I got out of it was that guy was around when the ability to program a computer wasn't a widely-available commodity. That's not to say that commodity programming ability and straightforward ideas allied to some business nous can't be successful nowadays - there are a lot of channels for doing that today that don't involve persuading ignorant HR staff to become the apprentice in their IT department, and no shortage of mentors to point you in the direction of independence. It's just that other people's very different experiences don't necessarily translate well into the impetus to do something different.

FWIW I got my youthful enterprise anecdotes from my grandpa's stories of an ancestor who taught himself how to build one of the first motor cars in the county, and never once felt the inclination to get out the monkey wrench. The interwebby stuff... I should have done more a long time ago.

Re:Your own company? You can do it by lionhearted on Saturday March 05, 2011 @04:19AM (#2291163)
> The temptation of seeing this depressing bullshit upvoted is too much to resist.

♫ ... You can checkout any time you like... but you can never leave... ♫

(Did you know Hotel California was about heroin? That might actually be a valid comparison to HN...)

Re:Your own company? You can do it by David on Friday March 04, 2011 @04:26PM (#2289863)
On the one hand, a story like yours of success through sheer determination is awesome and uplifting. On the other hand, the idea of working that hard, for that long, is overwhelming to many.

A lot of people don't think themselves (and may not be) capable of the sustained effort you put in. (Generalizing from my own case is possibly unwarranted, but it's uncomfortable to say this about myself directly. =/ )

Re:Your own company? You can do it by lawnchair_larry on Friday March 04, 2011 @05:29PM (#2290083)
It's like that wise tigerblood celebrity once said - "Can't is the cancer of happen."

We need less bi-polar, and more bi-winning up in here.

Re:Your own company? You can do it by chc on Friday March 04, 2011 @07:59PM (#2290469)
I don't want to sound prudish, but can we please leave the pop-culture jokes at the expense of the mentally ill to other sites?
Re:Your own company? You can do it by gord on Friday March 04, 2011 @09:06PM (#2290604)
I remember writing a bit of assembler in A86 shareware on an 8086 machine with 640k RAM, 20Gb disk. One day I discovered it had a Hercules graphics card. Another day I found a book on TSR programs. Later came turbo C & turbo pascal, which I appreciated all the more after some lower level experimenting.

What I do find remarkable is that you started a company by 22... I would have loved to have done that but maybe just didn't believe it was possible at the time.

Am enjoying reading HandBook Freemium.

Re:Your own company? You can do it by hacker-gene on Friday March 04, 2011 @09:07PM (#2290605)
The story was impressive, more so because you have high credibility in HN community. But inspiring? perhaps. I'm your usual hoi polloi tech support/sysad worker, it took me ages to to get comfortable in programming. To hear someone learn and did the things you did as young man was more of a case of an exceptional programmer narrative against all odds. Perhaps if you glossed over the age-factored accomplishment (it did jumped out at you) it would been more accessible and more life-lesson like, and the hard work you've put in would have been more pronounced. As it is, your life story was impressive and you were exceptional.

Great post and more power!

Re:Your own company? You can do it by TheSOB88 on Friday March 04, 2011 @05:24PM (#2290064)
So you came back to argue with what you basically sum up as a troll?

How a story makes you feel is probably the most important part of it. And I agree with Max: I feel disconnected from the person who says they were hacking awesome crap back when they were 16. I feel even more so because I almost had that opportunity - I learned Basic on my uncle's old C64 when I was 8! I wanted compilers so bad, I read C++ Windows API books from the library without any idea what the hell they meant, but nobody was there to guide me. I gave up. I know it's a bad way of looking at it, but I felt kind of cheated by the universe.

And implying that you need to be that kind of person - who has been hacking since their teens - to succeed, yeah, that makes me feel like I can't do it. I mean Jacques, come on. From that story it seems you a computing god at 17. And my 17-year-old parallel, writing some dumb Java apps, pales in comparison.

Re:Your own company? You can do it by ra88it on Friday March 04, 2011 @06:27PM (#2290250)
Agreed. I mean, here's the description of his first attempt at helping somebody with a computing problem:

I looked at their code for a bit, saw that it was hopelessly inefficient and hand-assembled a much faster version using a look-up table and a bit mask instead of a bunch of math to figure out where in memory to dump the data from the converter.

I feel exactly the same way as parent and grandparent when I read stories like this.