(a) Novelty; Prior Art- A person shall be entitled to a patent unless--
(1) the claimed invention was patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale, or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date of the claimed invention;
... it seems to indicate that prior art is still applicable when considering the validity of the patent. However, it's still not clear to me if prior art can be applied after the fact, or just during that 9 month period.
That seems to imply that if unpatented prior art by author A is discovered after author B applies for a patent, and the patent is invalidated, then author A cannot apply for patent. Interesting.
Or, perhaps first-to-file only applies when the reduction to practice is the act of filing a patent, rather than the act of publishing. In other words, it only applies in the special case that two people apply for patents on work that neither of them have published.
That would seem to imply that rather than applying for a patent, one should just publish.
I started to poke through the bill and the patent code to figure this out, but it's beyond me. Maybe I need more than 2 hours of sleep.
Things that are patentable could be made not patentable simply by publishing it.
- A patent cannot be challenged on the basis of prior art once issued
or:
- If two people independently invent something, and both apply for the patent, the first one to get to the patent office gets the patent, rather than the first one to document the idea. That documentation would still be prior art, though.
People who think it's the latter tend to like first-to-file. People who think it's the former tend to not. I haven't actually heard from a patent lawyer about it, though.