Re:Myhrvold: $700M in licensing revenue in 2010, $2B to date
by gbhn on Friday March 04, 2011 @12:51PM
(#2288984)
The trade-off question is whether these temporary monopolies encourage innovation and therefore improve overall utility. I think the balance right now is on "no," since the trade-off is predicated on the monopolist teaching in the patent how to implement the invention, and in it being novel and non-obvious. At this point, patents seem written explicitly to avoid teaching and to maximize footprint, and are very frequently not novel and/or obvious, yet the default judgment of the patent office is to be optimistic about applications. We basically need the courts to invalidate a ton of patents which are vague and obscure (don't teach the method in a useful way), and a ton more which are obvious (describe ways to use general-purpose tools in one of their intended uses, for example, like one-click) or not novel. That'd put a damper on it. Unless all east Texas courthouses are nuked from orbit, though, this probably won't happen. :-/
Smart people will always find a way to exploit a weak system. We can point at the exploiters and cry foul or we can thank them for spotting the bugs and change the system. Hopefully we can do that before they purchase all the votes in Congress. Or is it too late?