Re:37Signals "just says no" to feature request: "please fix ...
by goodkarma on Thursday June 26, 2008 @02:37PM
(#228937)
The issue here is not about adding new features, but fixing bugs and security issues.
Perhaps the 94% are not tech savvy enough to identify these problems?
Incidentally, I've read that specific example of adding Gantt charts to Basecamp before: http://www.37signals.com/svn/posts/1050-ask-37signals-how-do...
Re:37Signals "just says no" to feature request: "please fix ...
by Husafan on Thursday June 26, 2008 @01:21PM
(#228825)
Very nicely worded. Now, can address the OP's concern about security flaws not being fixed? Is security flaw == to Gantt chart request?
Re:37Signals "just says no" to feature request: "please fix ...
by tptacek on Thursday June 26, 2008 @01:35PM
(#228839)
The curators at the museums don't lock the doors and arm the alarms, Jason.
Re:37Signals "just says no" to feature request: "please fix ...
by Harkins on Thursday June 26, 2008 @03:37PM
(#228995)
I'm surprised that so few Basecamp users would recommend it. 94% is not a good number, you have to take into account survivorship bias. The people who would not recommend your service have already stopped being your customers. 94% says that your churn rate is 6%.
But, we also get thousands of requests a year so we can't do everything everyone wants. Many of these requests conflict with one another, and many of them just aren't a good fit for our products (adding Gantt charts to Basecamp, for example). The good ones, however, often make it into the products eventually. Sometimes exactly as requested, sometimes in a different form, but customer requests are almost always the seeds of improvement.
It is our job to be editors and museum curators. We have to decide what makes it and what doesn't for the benefit of the overall product and the overall customer base. No combination of yes or no is going to satisfy everyone, so we have to work on behalf of the majority.
Every company with millions of users has to say no more than they say yes, we're just honest and up front about it about it. We don't want to set false expectations or promise things we won't be able to deliver.
While this policy may rub some people the wrong way, we think it's the right policy. And seeing that 94%+ of our customers would recommend Basecamp to a friend or colleague, I think we're on the right track. http://basecamphq.com/survey