Are there other examples of "we chose to go to market like this (x, y, z reasons) and here's why"?
I am currently using logdna as my splunk alternative, but it's not very good.
Why should I try scalyr next, over the other alternatives ?
My main constraint is the solution should be at least half as good as splunk, and cost less than $50 a month (I generate less than 1G a day).
Your pricing seems to be reasonable. But how do you compare to splunk on features ?
Here are the other tools I am considering trying
You can find a more general overview at https://scalyr.com/product.
Seems like you guys fit the bill. I'll do the 30 day trial, and see how it goes. Thanks for the response.
Steve says elsewhere in the thread that Splunk has the more-flexible query language, and while that may be true I as a product engineer never noticed the delta myself.
TL;DR I think you'd be doing yourself a favor to try Scalyr, and I have no affiliation other than being a happy former customer.
Disclaimer: I'm one of the founders. We built it to be a Splunk alternative and I think it does a great job from a data ingest, scalability, and data querying perspective. We're lacking some of the out-of-the-box capability, but not for long. Kits (our "apps") release is coming this quarter.
This is a very nice way of framing the question.
I think there may be at least two scenarios to consider. For some products, cost is primarily driven by R&D; for others, cost of operating the service (COGS) dominates. Of course it's a continuum, but I suspect there are more services near the ends than the middle.
For an R&D-dominated service, if your needs are nontrivial and there is an off-the-shelf product that is a decent fit, you probably want to go off-the-shelf. A commercial provider can amortize the R&D over a large customer base.
For a COGS-dominated service, the commercial provider may still be more efficient but it is less of a slam dunk. Log management (e.g. Splunk) involves a substantial operational component, because you're dealing with large volumes of data.
Disclaimer: I am the founder of Scalyr, a Splunk competitor. Early on we realized that, even though log management is COGS-heavy, we could achieve huge economies of scale, because query workloads are highly bursty. By carefully managing a central pool of resources shared by many clients, we're able to run much more efficiently than a single-tenant homegrown solution [1]. This is one of the key points that we highlight when having build vs. buy discussions with potential customers.
[1] https://www.scalyr.com/blog/searching-1tb-sec-systems-engine...