Re:Colornames.org – A collaborative effort to name all 16.7M...
by tzs on Monday April 13, 2020 @12:06PM
(#22857025)
Let's do an example, using just colors with no red or green in their RGB representation so we just have to give the B component, which is a decimal from from 0 to 255. Let's call 0 "black".
Your suggestion was that if a color is close enough to another to be indistinguishable it the two should have the same name.
1 is close enough to 0, so gets the name "black" too.
How about 2? That's farther from 0 "black". Is it distinguishable? If not, it too is "black", and we can go on to compare 3 and 0, and beyond.
At some point we get our lowest blue-only RGB color that is distinguishable from 0 "black". Suppose that is 4. So we have 0, 1, 2, and 3 are all called "black", and since 4 is distinguishable from 0 it needs a new name, say "very light blue".
But now we have 3 "black" only 1 away from 4 "very light blue". Those are probably indistinguishable, so are supposed to have the same name. Oops.
Your suggestion was that if a color is close enough to another to be indistinguishable it the two should have the same name.
1 is close enough to 0, so gets the name "black" too.
How about 2? That's farther from 0 "black". Is it distinguishable? If not, it too is "black", and we can go on to compare 3 and 0, and beyond.
At some point we get our lowest blue-only RGB color that is distinguishable from 0 "black". Suppose that is 4. So we have 0, 1, 2, and 3 are all called "black", and since 4 is distinguishable from 0 it needs a new name, say "very light blue".
But now we have 3 "black" only 1 away from 4 "very light blue". Those are probably indistinguishable, so are supposed to have the same name. Oops.