Then they are asking for exactly the kind of 'answer to a question that was never asked' that the Supreme Court told all courts to stop giving.
One doesn't preclude the other.
It would simultaneously federalize elections, and subvert Congress.
You really don't want a bunch of appointed-for-life judges to have total control over all elections in the country.
The Constitution has little to say about voting, but we all know voting is a complex topic. Voting policy should come from the legislature and SCOTUS should merely oversee it.
I can understand folks being concerned / upset that SCOTUS wasn't involved, and they can too still recognize that the question maybe wasn't really posed to SCOTUS.
I suppose anything 'could' be a voting rights issue, but the important thing is to actually talk about what that anything is. Limited polling places, being required to wait hours, risk your own health to vote ... to me there is an argument to be made there.
I'm not at all sure what your comment about judges deciding are... a judge(s) did decide already.
If that was even an option for them to do is still relevant of course.