News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by fulafel on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:56AM (#22855838)
Why do consumers allow games to install these kind of kernel drivers? Are they aware they are giving away keys to the kindom wrt the OS/computing environment integrity just so game studios can take part in an unwinnable cat and mouse chase with cheaters? Also why does Microsoft or AV products allow this without giant "you are giving away root on your box" warning signs?
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by hombre_fatal on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:59AM (#22855860)
People don't know what a kernel driver is nor what root access is nor what it entails. I don't think the installer even mentions it, either. They just want to play the dang game. Remember when Vista launched with that UAC prompt and people just googled how to perma-disable it?

Also, cheating really is so bad that most people will accept it anyways.

Unfortunately we don't have a software nor user culture of, for example, having an isolated partition for our important files and an isolated partition for "I just want to play some games" -- You can imagine how streamlined and effortless and by-default this could be in an alternate universe where it was a top priority.

So people can really get hosed under catastrophic conditions like the anti-cheat becoming a remote backdoor for an attacker. I think this is really where people are let down by modern computing.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by GuB-42 on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:34AM (#22856172)
That isolated environment is called a game console.

We are in a weird situation with PC gaming. PCs have always been a hackers friendly platform. Both Counterstrike and DOTA started as mods. Skyrim is more of a platform than a game now. Of course, it also means cheating, but it wasn't a big deal back then. Cheaters were just shunned, or sometimes encouraged, depending on the context. No big money at stake, no big deal.

But now, we want a standardized platform for high stakes competitive play, so why not bring back consoles. They are more than powerful enough for this, and you can hook up a keyboard and mouse if you want.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by leetcrew on Monday April 13, 2020 @11:13AM (#22856523)
people that play cs for real money target ~144 fps as the 99th percentile minimum. consoles aren't really designed for this use case.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by falcolas on Monday April 13, 2020 @01:16PM (#22857738)
Not sure why this has been downvoted, it’s strictly true. The console is not a reasonable platform for a competitive game which is cross-platform.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by leetcrew on Monday April 13, 2020 @01:35PM (#22857956)
I think GP was suggesting that competitive titles should only be released on consoles, so that everyone would have a sandboxed environment with intrusive anticheat. my point is more that the hardware in current consoles isn't really suited for esports titles. consoles are mainly designed to run AAA games without dropping below 60 fps too often. this means selecting a relatively weak CPU so you can allocate more of the budget towards the GPU, which will usually be the bottleneck in this sort of game. you usually want the opposite tradeoff for esports; the graphics are not particularly fancy so you can get by with a middling GPU, but you care a lot more about fps, so you want a faster CPU. counterstrike in particular is almost completely bottlenecked by singlethread performance. even with a 9900k, a discrete gpu is barely above idle.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by falcolas on Monday April 13, 2020 @03:33PM (#22859193)
> consoles are mainly designed to run AAA games without dropping below 60 fps too often

This is not actually the case. It's part of what makes Doom's aiming for (and, with Doom eternal actually hitting) 60fps an exception. Most AAA games (including competitive games like COD) prioritize visuals over frame rate, and so they are typically aiming for 25-30 FPS.

Also, a number of graphical workloads are still bound by the CPU - such as occlusion culling.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by BoorishBears on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:26AM (#22856104)
> Also, cheating really is so bad that most people will accept it anyways.

I feel this is the part people miss. It's true that it's a cat and mouse game and these end up still being worked around, but cheating has crippled games before.

Search any popular game + "cheaters" and find thousands of posts complaining about these people.

Even if you explain this stuff to people, and admit it's still not foolproof, they will embrace it.

I think we see this mistake a lot in the tech bubble. People assume if only people knew their data was being used they'd be outraged, except if you give them a choice between that and paying for stuff they'll always take giving away their data.

People just don't care that much about the digital "realm". Their online presence, their "digital rights", to them it's all ethereal and a lot of the few who are even aware of this stuff assume the fight is lost anyways, further whittling down the number of people who care.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by TrinaryWorksToo on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:28AM (#22856121)
I find that odd. I think that most people can't afford the prices asked to keep their data.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by BoorishBears on Monday April 13, 2020 @12:00PM (#22856968)
I mean, I feel like ad services are not making such unaffordable amounts of revenue per user. Facebook reports $112 of revenue per user in the US, and that number plummets to just $25 globally.

Facebook is the privacy boogeyman these days, jokes about Zuckerberg are in no short supply.

Yet if you told people you can pay $9 a month and Facebook never needs your data ever again except host it for you, they'd say no. In fact they might be insulted you had the audacity to ask for such a thing. You could ask for $1 and they'd still say no.

It's just the same way they don't value their digital presence, they don't value digital goods and services.

They'll pay $6 every morning for the same cup of coffee worth 30 cents of ingredients and 5 minutes of work, but balk at the idea of an app asking for 99 cents for a lifetime of development work.

I'm not saying that from a place of bitterness to be clear, it's just what I've found to be the inconvenient reality of things.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by gameswithgo on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:24AM (#22856095)
>take part in an unwinnable cat and mouse chase with cheaters?

It may be unwinnable, but it is "mitigateable". It is much better to have your game ruined once a week by a cheater instead of 5 times a day. It can be a perfectly reasonable trade off if the game is important to you.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by jasonlotito on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:10AM (#22855949)
> Why do consumers allow games to install these kind of kernel drivers?

They want to play the game.

> Are they aware they are giving away keys to the kindom wrt the OS/computing environment integrity just so game studios can take part in an unwinnable cat and mouse chase with cheaters?

They are aware that even if cheaters will always exist, they accept that the anti-cheating measures will stop most people from cheating. As for giving away the keys to the kingdom, everyone already accepts that from Microsoft, a company they apparently trust. Why wouldn't they accept that from another company they trust?

> Also why does Microsoft or AV products allow this without giant "you are giving away root on your box" warning signs?

Because people didn't like that, they were mocked for it, and people became numb to the requests. So they still have warning signs, they are just toned down.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by jjoonathan on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:00AM (#22855863)
Because people want to play games and https://xkcd.com/1200/
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by fulafel on Monday April 13, 2020 @11:08AM (#22856472)
This XKCD point is not wrong, but it's also a kind of whataboutism: Windows as used by most users is not very good at protecting user data since unsandboxed applications are typically all run as the same user with free access to all the account's files.

Most platforms are edging towards sandboxing applications, with OS X app store, UWP, and the various Linux snap/flatpak/appimage etc things. Web apps and iOS/Android have their own tings.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by swinglock on Monday April 13, 2020 @12:00PM (#22856965)
But this is literally only about Windows. It's a Windows kernel module used for a Windows only video game. What do you call that fallacy?
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by jsjddbbwj on Monday April 13, 2020 @01:26PM (#22857865)
These kernel mode drivers would also exist for Linux if someone actually made games for Linux.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by gnulinux on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:01AM (#22855875)
I don't get this xkcd. If you steal my computer while I'm logged in you can't log into my bank account of you don't know the password. Which bank has indefinitely long sessions? Mine's time out after like 10 mins of inactivity.

The only plausible attack scenario is if you steal my computer while I'm logged into my KeePassX. It has all my passwords visible. But that session times out as well.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by valiant55 on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:07AM (#22855929)
I mean, if you are logged into your email that's pretty much game over for most sites including possibly your bank.

Just request a password reset and change it to whatever you'd like.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by geofft on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:07AM (#22855925)
There's two didn't attack models, "steals permanently" and "runs code on and returns to you" (which includes both "steals from your hotel room and puts back" or "installs malware on"). Yes, for the first one it's hard to get to the bank account and I agree the comic is inaccurate. For the second, it's very easy to install a keylogger or a cookie-logger or a malicious browser extension or whatever.

Riot installing a kernel module is more like the latter.

Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by oldmanhorton on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:05AM (#22855907)
I assume most people use the browser built in password manager with no master password. If you can launch chrome, you're in.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by zwily on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:40AM (#22856231)
Safari’s password manager requires TouchID or entering your computer password on every password retrieval.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by mrkramer on Monday April 13, 2020 @11:46AM (#22856820)
Chrome's as well.
Re:Riot Games newest title “Valorant” installs kernel driver... by kgwxd on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:30AM (#22856140)
title="Before you say anything, no, I know not to leave my computer sitting out logged in to all my accounts. I have it set up so after a few minutes of inactivity it automatically switches to my brother's."