News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Piracy is Theft? Ridiculous. Lost Sales? They Don’t Exist by henrikschroder on Thursday March 03, 2011 @11:22AM (#2284589)
> My experience with the issue includes an incident where an organization with revenues in the multiple billions of dollars used the software I built

I'm pretty sure noone here thinks that that specific case is ok.

Technically there's no difference between that company pirating your software and someone illegaly downloading a movie off of the internet, the crime is the same, both actions are copyright infringement.

But the main arguments of the pirate movement is that there is a difference between the actions and that the law should reflect that. Arguing that private non-commercial infringement should be allowed is different from arguing that commercial for-profit infringement should be allowed. There's a lot of people in this thread arguing the former, but noone arguing the latter.

Re:Piracy is Theft? Ridiculous. Lost Sales? They Don’t Exist by macrael on Thursday March 03, 2011 @12:22PM (#2284844)
Doesn't that thinking discourage the creation of consumer software? Just because someone isn't making money off of my software doesn't make it ok for them to have it for free.
Re:Piracy is Theft? Ridiculous. Lost Sales? They Don’t Exist by cemerick on Thursday March 03, 2011 @01:17PM (#2285082)
That's absurd. The law is the law, and people that produce content, software, whatever for non-commercial/personal/consumer consumption have the same standing as I do as a commercial vendor, and should have the same standing.

Infringement is infringement. Arguing otherwise smacks of opportunism to me; people just like getting shit for free.

Re:Piracy is Theft? Ridiculous. Lost Sales? They Don’t Exist by henrikschroder on Thursday March 03, 2011 @02:00PM (#2285274)
> The law is the law

Laws can, and should, change if society changes.

> people that produce content, software, whatever for non-commercial/personal/consumer consumption have the same standing as I do as a commercial vendor, and should have the same standing.

I agree, I don't think there should be differentiation based on how or why something copyrighted was produced.

However, I don't agree that all infringement is equal, there's a huge difference between some kid downloading a movie off of the internet, and a corporation using a piece of software without a license. I think it's absurd to use the resources of our justice system and law enforcement to pursue the former, but I think it's a great use to pursue the latter.

Re:Piracy is Theft? Ridiculous. Lost Sales? They Don’t Exist by cemerick on Thursday March 03, 2011 @02:16PM (#2285335)
We're largely in agreement, then. Repercussions should vary with the magnitude of the infringement. Various industry groups managing to get individuals fined for out-sized sums, jail time for parents of downloaders, etc., are out of bounds. I see no problem with things being ratcheted up for big seeders and such though.

I think the law is going to be behind the times for a long time on this topic; in part because of the tech, and in part because we are, broadly speaking, divided on what a better direction would be. In any case, I'd hate to see a day come when it's generally agreed that authors of content and software fundamentally don't have the right – if they so choose – to demand payment in exchange for their creations being used, consumed, and distributed.