News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by SpicyLemonZest on Friday April 10, 2020 @01:57PM (#22835536)
I'm extremely skeptical of any analysis that discusses political non-viability at this point. If you asked any commentator 2 months ago whether it was politically viable to issue general stay at home orders, or to give every American a bunch of free money, or to pass a multi-trillion dollar stimulus bill, they would have told you no.
Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by ztjio on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:21PM (#22835848)
Giving every American a token cash handout is something Republicans have done before, it's hardly unbelievable if you actually have historical context. And by far most of that bill is corporate handouts. And the oversight has been fired. Everything about this aligns exactly with what you'd expect politically. It's a debacle.

Furthermore, while there has been a lot of shutdown, it's not equal across the board. Tons of places are taking half measures or no measures still, and the reasoning is entirely politically biased (business more important than people, etc.) It's clearly a case of more right leaning areas taking less cautious measures in favor of money.

In fact, I'd argue that everything that has happened, especially all the horribly obvious "mistakes" (read: intentional, corruption riddle, failures in the case of the federal administration) aligns with political viability as expected and confirms in retrospect the claims about viability.

Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by LyndsySimon on Friday April 10, 2020 @03:15PM (#22836374)
> It's clearly a case of more right leaning areas taking less cautious measures in favor of money.

While I see where you’re coming from with this statement, I’m not sure I agree. From where I stand - a town of 13k people surrounded by a large rural area - it makes sense that we’re taking less aggressive action because the virus is not yet endemic here. Given the growth of confirmed cases in my area (northern Arkansas), it seems those steps are working adequately to keep it from becoming endemic as well.

I propose that areas with lower population density are taking less aggressive action, and those areas are also predominately right-leaning.

Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by ztjio on Friday April 10, 2020 @05:22PM (#22837492)
Literally everyone in this scenario thinks this way at first because they can't comprehend exponential growth. Nobody can, there are actual studies that show nobody can understand it so it's not a slight.

The only way you can convince me based on evidence elsewhere that your scenario is going to be any better than anywhere else is if your leadership in your area is doing aggressive testing, contact tracing and targeted isolation protocols akin to South Korea.

Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by burfog on Saturday April 11, 2020 @05:55AM (#22840758)
Consider the R0 value that you're trying to reduce by social distancing.

New York City starts with a high value. People encounter each other in apartment hallways, packed subways, crowded streets, and huge stadiums.

Rural places don't have any of that. People don't pass by any non-family when going from home to car. Non-family don't share that car. The streets are nearly empty of people, with just the occasional person out walking a dog.

There might not be exponential growth. If R0 is below 1, there is exponential decay.

Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by SpicyLemonZest on Friday April 10, 2020 @05:50PM (#22837703)
I'm not sure why it's a question of "going to be". The scenario in most states is better than New York, and has been for a while, even though many of them confirmed their first case earlier.
Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by LyndsySimon on Saturday April 11, 2020 @03:11PM (#22843471)
I’ve been watching this situation for months at this point, so I can assure you I’m personally taking it seriously.

It’s not that my area is taking no measures at all - only that we’re being much less aggressive about it than other areas. All of the restaurants are closed for dine-in, as many as possible are working from home, and we’re social distancing.

The governor of Arkansas is convinced that is enough. So far - at least for the area where I live - that does indeed seem to be the case. There have been a total of five confirmed positives in my county, and one of them is already listed as recovered. The data are not above teh noise floor, so it’s hard to be completely sure, but it really looks like we’re succeeding in keeping it from getting a foothold here.

Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by SpicyLemonZest on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:47PM (#22836147)
You're not wrong, but the first part is largely what I'm talking about. When people say something is "light-years beyond the kind of political leadership and public-private coordination we’ve seen thus far", I don't think they're doing a principled analysis of what political leadership or coordination has been able to accomplish in the past.
Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by austingulati on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:40PM (#22836063)
I have seen a few click-bait headlines stating that the "oversight was fired" but it is not exactly true. There is some politics going on about who is chair of the PRAC but the other ~20 members of the committee have not changed.
Re:The plans to reopen the economy are scary by ztjio on Friday April 10, 2020 @05:24PM (#22837506)
The procession of a dictator is more nuanced and complex than people realize. A totally typical tactic is to repeatedly fire anyone who will take up the role in a fashion that does not directly benefit said dictator. That anyone was fired from this duty without a clear explanation and justification is cause for alarm. It doesn't matter if there are 20 or 2000 more ready to step into that position. Dictator will keep firing until he sees a loyal drone in the slot.