News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mental models around Ok-Wrapping by eximius on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:22AM (#22833932)
How does the error case break the monadic model? All of the monad rules still apply, I think.
Re:Mental models around Ok-Wrapping by pinopinopino on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:36AM (#22834096)
The error needs to be a monoid to be able to flatten the Result, if it is not, it will break, you will lose information. E.g. if you have:

      R<E1,R<E2,A>> -- flatten --> R<E1 + E2, A>
R stands for result, E1,E2 are errors.

You need to think up a reasonable implementation of +. This is of course easily solvable, you can just add them together. Keep a list of errors in your result instead of one error and you are done. Just keep the +, it is free :p

Re:Mental models around Ok-Wrapping by lmm on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:46AM (#22834206)
This is completely wrong. Result is either success or failure, so an R<E1, R<E2, A>> can never contain both E1 and E2 at the same time.

Validation types work the way you describe and require a monoidal "error" side, but famously do not form monads (though they are applicative functors).

Re:Mental models around Ok-Wrapping by pinopinopino on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:58AM (#22834324)
A true that, long day and have been working with shapeless in scala, where type level and value level mixes up :)
Re:Mental models around Ok-Wrapping by eximius on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:55AM (#22834302)
While compelling, flattening doesn't make something a monad, does it? Not snark, if that's a consequence of one of the three laws, I'm just unaware of it. I know what monads are but I'm not practised with them.

But of left identity, right identity, and associativity, what is violated?

Re:Mental models around Ok-Wrapping by pinopinopino on Friday April 10, 2020 @12:08PM (#22834404)
So, I was a bit wrong with the monoid, I meant to add them on typelevel by using a sumtype. Sorry, sometimes bit confused after work.

No flattening doesn't make something a monad. Return and flattening are the interesting operations of a monad, that together with the laws makes the monad.

>But of left identity, right identity, and associativity, what is violated?

Well, there is not something violated perse, but you cannot write a flatten operation for something like this:

     R<R<u32, E1>, E2>
However you could write it for this:

         R<R<u32, E1 + E2>, E1 + E2>
(That was what I should have written above btw) Because now the error types are the same.
Re:Mental models around Ok-Wrapping by bcheung on Friday April 10, 2020 @12:26PM (#22834587)
I created a Result style interface in Typescript and made the decisions to fix the Error to a single type for this very reason.

Result<T> instead of Result<T,E> so that it was easier to compose.

This made Kleisli composition easier since I don't have to worry about mismatched types on the Error.

You can see the code at https://github.com/brennancheung/wasmtalk/blob/master/src/fp...

Re:Mental models around Ok-Wrapping by whelming_wave on Friday April 10, 2020 @07:50PM (#22838553)
I've found this kind of pattern much nicer in an application context. Rust sort of has this going on with anyhow[1] for applications and thiserror[2] for libraries (or just writing your own Error type).

[1]: https://crates.io/crates/anyhow

[2]: https://crates.io/crates/thiserror