News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For 40 Years, This Russian Family Was Cut Off from All Hu... by int_19h on Thursday April 09, 2020 @07:11PM (#22828188)
Whether that verse is abrogated or not is a matter of debate in Islam, particularly when it comes to its specific meaning (i.e. many would say that it's not abrogated, but that's because it only applied in the original context of Muhammad's conquests, and is not a broad commandment).
Re:For 40 Years, This Russian Family Was Cut Off from All Hu... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday April 11, 2020 @06:22AM (#22840891)
In Islam, to my understanding, Mohammed is the paragon, the perfect example to be imitated in all things.

Do you have a source that you've found convincing on those surah being abrogated?

Presumably sources that say that was only for Mohammed necessarily would condemn his warring (making him not a paragon, and destroying a central premise), and what of the caliphs that followed Mohammed. I'd be interested in a mainstream condemnation of Islamic military expansion, if there is one?

Re:For 40 Years, This Russian Family Was Cut Off from All Hu... by int_19h on Monday April 13, 2020 @12:35AM (#22853209)
Imitation also has to consider conquest. So again the question becomes whether it was a general guideline for warfare, or specific to the particular circumstances of the specific conflict that Muhammad was engaged in at the time. So far as I know, the mainstream position is that it is the latter. It doesn't mean that they're abrogated - it just means that a similar situation is unlikely to arise again. It also doesn't imply a condemnation of war.

Even the "righteous" caliphs did all kinds of things contradicting the Sunnah, so I don't think that's a very useful yardstick. But overall, given that the Caliphate had plenty - indeed, early after the initial conquests, the majority of its population - following different religions, it's pretty obvious that the commandment wasn't taken quite so verbatim even then. And, on the other hand, consider the ultimate fate of the Kharijites, who kinda took it to heart.