News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tuple Spaces (or, Good Ideas Don’t Always Win) by jerf on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @09:26PM (#2282447)
Has anyone successfully used this for anything significant? As I post this there's only a couple of people posting about how either they tried but it didn't work out well enough, or they just played with it in school without any code.

It strikes me as having the same problems as RDF storage; precisely because the model is so general, there's nothing for optimizations to grab on to and optimize on. Your database has to stand ready to do anything equally. The core of database optimization is, when you really get down to it, working out how to tell your database which things you really want and what you will never care about, as in "This table has twenty columns but I will only query on name and phone number". In practice, limitations aren't always just there because of a lack of imagination or insufficient computer science education (though that does happen), sometimes they're there because you can't get any performance without them.

Re:Tuple Spaces (or, Good Ideas Don’t Always Win) by mmastrac on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @09:38PM (#2282491)
I did a post-grad project using JavaSpaces and prolog to do automated refactoring in Java back in the late 90's. The JavaSpaces implementation was so terrible that it was hard to get anything done. Great idea, but poor execution in Java probably killed Jini and JavaSpaces (and any hope of it going mainstream).
Re:Tuple Spaces (or, Good Ideas Don’t Always Win) by spaznode on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @10:11PM (#2282605)
We used JavaSpaces/Jini in an EMRS system during the same period(and also tried GigaSpaces which was best impl) called Frontiers which was at some point used at many hospitals on both coasts.

It did make things very flexible as in we knew we could just start ripping pieces out of the system during testing to make sure every piece was completely autonomous and definitely redundant with data. Also had "agents" in self contained "hot reloadable" classes because we learned about the discarded classloader trick. Man, learned so much fun/crazy stuff at that job.

Re:Tuple Spaces (or, Good Ideas Don’t Always Win) by sleight42 on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @11:25PM (#2282817)
Sure. I used a TupleSpace for an impromptu map-reduce for some heavy duty number-crunching across multiple cores and physical machines.
Re:Tuple Spaces (or, Good Ideas Don’t Always Win) by mikebike on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @10:19PM (#2282629)
There's a commercial computational chemistry software package called Gaussian that uses Linda: http://gaussian.com/g_prod/linda.htm
Re:Tuple Spaces (or, Good Ideas Don’t Always Win) by regularfry on Thursday March 03, 2011 @02:51AM (#2283236)
Yeah, I've used Rinda for load balancing across small numbers of machines before. It's a couple of screens of ruby in total to get that working, which I was astonished by.
Re:Tuple Spaces (or, Good Ideas Don’t Always Win) by cromulent on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @10:23PM (#2282647)