News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the Dollar's Reign Is Near an End by btilly on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:06PM (#2280734)
We just approved a short term spending bill to push off the government shut down. Yay, us.

However it should be noted that if the government shuts down for long enough, we won't pay our bond obligations. This would be serious. Very serious. In fact the last time there was a shut down there were two, with a small gap in the middle as everyone agreed to a temporary emergency measure that avoided missing bond obligations.

This time around as shutdown looms, we'll see whether Congress keeps this in mind. They are playing a game of chicken. But if the game of chicken results in the USA failing to pay our bond obligations on time, even once, we instantly lose the perception that US treasuries are absolutely risk free investments. If that happens, our desirability as a currency goes down, our interest rates go up, and our dollar is likely to drop relatively quickly. The real nightmare is that this becomes an accelerating spiral.

The odds of this scenario is unlikely. Washington is full of grandstanding politicians, but those politicians do have intelligent advisers. The consequences of this one are rather dramatic and well understood. But occasionally I worry about it.

Re:Why the Dollar's Reign Is Near an End by jerf on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:23PM (#2280806)
To the extent that people are talking about a shutdown, it has been with the idea that a resolution will be passed to pay our bond and entitlement obligations while everything else is shut down.

It should be pointed out that we have enough income to cover those things in the absence of other discretionary spending, so that does not require more debt.

A government shutdown will not be accompanied by the financial fireworks that people are anticipating. Personally I'm all for this style of shutdown. The savings are immense and quick and I daresay a lot of people will be quite shocked to learn just how little we need all those government services. I'm not saying we don't need them at all, just that we need them far less that people think. We managed to live without them for quite a while, after all.

Re:Why the Dollar's Reign Is Near an End by btilly on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:38PM (#2281184)
In the mid-90s the Republicans believed that people would be surprised at how little they missed government services. Then the news was full of things like people whose vacation plans were ruined by the fact that national parks were closed. Or people whose travel plans were disrupted because they couldn't get visas. Or people who were being laid off because their employer was running out of money due to the shutdown. People blamed the Republicans for it and it was a disaster.

Sure, most people weren't impacted. But news organizations are in the business of finding human interest stories. And all of the human interest stories that you can find around a government shutdown are pretty bad. There will be a backlash. The only question is who the public decides should be blamed. Given that people hate Congress more than anyone else in the government, I would bet they'll blame Congress. (Again.)

As for the savings that you are hoping for, that is not so clear either.

First there is a direct cost to shutting down the government. People have to put their paperwork in order. You need to hire more security guards. And so on. An estimate I heard on NPR is that the last time the cost of shutting down the government was estimated at half a billion.

But then you don't even save that much money. Much of the work that government does is work they are mandated to do. If nobody does it, the paperwork piles up. When they start up again it is piled high, and you need to have people work overtime or hire more until you've worked through the backlogs. In the end you've done similar work, paid similar money for it (actually you may have paid more for overtime), and haven't really saved a lot of what you thought you did.