You're completely correct. What I was trying to communicate, and what I should have emphasized, is that it's not just a send and forget kind of process. After the items have been set aside you get an email/text to confirm that things are ready to pickup and in my experience everything that I've ordered is there when I go to pick it up. So I'm saying that the things that were listed as in stock on the website are actually in stock at the store, and I get a confirmation once everything has been "secured" for me.
We can break down your two statements and put them piecemeal side by side:
I assumed they meant... "hold these..."
What I am saying is... "pulling the items from the shelf..."
I assumed they meant... "at the counter..."
What I am saying is... "in a special area..."