You are essentially identifying the semantic divergence between Church and Curry style types. Church-style or Intrinsically typed Lambda Calculus does not give any meaning to ill-typed expressions and there for beta-reduction can not proceed for these invalid expressions. Where as Curry-style or Extrinsically typed lambda calculus gives meaning to expression that do not consider the type alleged to be possessed by that expression.

The crucial difference between Church and Curry is that Curry allows each term to be ascribed a set of types - perhaps 0, 1 or many - whereas Church insists on each term having exactly one (often annotated). Both are systems for proving type correctness of terms.