Re:70% of the Public Finds Piracy Socially Acceptable
by jasonlotito on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @08:26AM
(#2279429)
> Yes, though how responsible you are is debatable. Intent is important but ignorance is rarely a successful defense.
Their was no intent. Someone was merely able to gain access to the computer without my expressed knowledge and download a file (hypothetical, of course).
> Why wouldn't you be?
I guess your assuming I've given them explicit access to the FTP server.
> How is that any different? Or do you mean someone guessed the password?
Sorry, I tried to state the conditions. In the previous question it was merely that, I setup an FTP server, I don't password protect it, but I don't publish that the site exists.
So, yes, in the last question: someone guessed the password.
> Of course, most of these answers are just my opinion/speculation. Sometimes the line between "piracy" and "sharing" is blurry which I think is a huge part of the problem.
Agreed, which was the point of the exercise. We infer so much from simple actions. Intention is important, as you mentioned.
Their was no intent. Someone was merely able to gain access to the computer without my expressed knowledge and download a file (hypothetical, of course).
> Why wouldn't you be?
I guess your assuming I've given them explicit access to the FTP server.
> How is that any different? Or do you mean someone guessed the password?
Sorry, I tried to state the conditions. In the previous question it was merely that, I setup an FTP server, I don't password protect it, but I don't publish that the site exists.
So, yes, in the last question: someone guessed the password.
> Of course, most of these answers are just my opinion/speculation. Sometimes the line between "piracy" and "sharing" is blurry which I think is a huge part of the problem.
Agreed, which was the point of the exercise. We infer so much from simple actions. Intention is important, as you mentioned.