I have been looking at a handful of projects in this space, including notion.so and Roam, but am seriously considering moving back to Markdown-folder backed by Dropbox, for which there are a variety of editors including The Archive, and mobile apps too.
I urge you to allow zero-friction bidirectional sync at the very least. For me, unless I have complete data portability, a note-taking app that might disappear in a year is a non-starter for me.
[edit: I read deeper and see you have it, thank you]
Dividing layers is of course more work and has problems of it's own, but works well enough that AFAIK this org-roam here is doing under the hood too.
I actually switched to it from org-mode, but still edit the notes in emacs because of keymap (via "Edit in external editor" feature).
P.S. When I read bidirectional sync I misread it as bidirectional links, which is something we're working on as well!
I wanted a few things that Zim didn't offer, such as a quick PDF viewer, bib/reference entries, audio notes (embeddable), and space repetition for term/definition pairs. I realize these needs are highly personal and they will be plugins that you can enable/disable.
I didn't love the interface but it wasn't a deal breaker.
E.g., why not just use Markdown's existing syntax, like `[A File](a-file.md)`?
(Cool looking project by the way, all the values are right up my alley.)
There are 3 main reasons:
1) At least to me, "[Topic](Topic.md)" is the most typical case, where the name of the link is the same as the file name without the ".md", so I feel like not repeating the title twice is better.
Markdown supports "[](Topic.md)" but IMO the syntax doesn't look as nice.
2) Easier to distinguish between internal links and external links.
3) Personally, I think "[[note]]" blends into the sentence better.
[[wiki style links]] are not as portable as standard Markdown links, I have to admit that. We will support "[A File](a-file.md)" as well for maximum portability, and possibility provide conversion utilities if you decide to move away from the wiki style link syntax.
The vertical bar syntax is also supported, so you can write [[Topic|display name]] and "display name" will show.
I usually leave punctuation out of the link, like `[[name]]'s`.
> Also do both types of links provide the same affordances? If I write [[Topic]] vs [Topic](topic.md) is there any semantic difference?
No semantic different.
UX-wise, right now [[ auto-completes from the list of files in your folder, whereas [Topic]( doesn't.
The graph overview may seem like a gimmick, but it's surprisingly useful in reviewing stale notes. Tracing semantic connection is more fun than just browsing a folder.
It's also super nice to be able to embed local copies of PDFs, images, and voice notes, so I know as long as I back up my hard drive, I'll never lose them.
Next I want to add plugins to do periodic reviews of notes, and maybe space repetition for term/definition pairs. Honestly, these efforts only make sense when the data is available for the long haul.
[1]: https://obsidian.md/