News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All models are wrong, but some are completely wrong by DoofusOfDeath on Sunday April 05, 2020 @02:40PM (#22787459)
Regarding the "all models are wrong" maxim...

Is that statement 100% true for the low-level models that physicists use and develop? In particular, I'm curious if quantum-physics models are 100% right, just not 100% precise.

Re:All models are wrong, but some are completely wrong by qchris on Sunday April 05, 2020 @03:30PM (#22787898)
At the level that you're talking about, you'll start running into the unresolved questions of modern physics.

One of the best ways to look at this is through the Standard Model of particle physics, which essentially defines how the fundamental particles of the universe are related. Between the number of observations and large-scale experiments dealing with high-energy collision products, astrophysics, neutrino detectors, etc., some people consider the Standard Model to be the most thoroughly-tested and verified framework in all of science. That's a pretty grand claim, but hey.

But it still falls short in some ways--for one, it starts breaking down past a certain scale. Classical field theory as defined by general relativity (another model that has had enormous success under test both theoretically and experimentally) and particle physics don't get along. Neither one fully explains reality, and the interface between those two models of reality hasn't been found. That's why people research things like string theory--they're attempting to find a mathematical framework that can resolve those two frameworks, among other things.

So while each of them describes the universe extremely accurately in their own domain (check the sigma values and number of observations of experiments run on the LHC), they're not 100% right, since they can't be correctly extended to cover all scales and frames. The models remain just that--models which provide a useful framework to interpret reality, but don't fully describe the physical reality itself.

Re:All models are wrong, but some are completely wrong by lidHanteyk on Sunday April 05, 2020 @07:47PM (#22789713)
Yes, it is completely true, and not in a probabilistic way, either. A model is a mathematical construction which relates observations to predictions. However, there is no epistemic basis by which predictions can be turned into observations; we can never ultimately draw conclusions just based on inferences.

Perhaps you have heard of the idea that "the map is not the territory" [0]. Models can never be exactly descriptions of reality, not without some sort of special rationale and argument from the outside of reality.

In particular, QM models aren't 100% right. Gravity is missing almost entirely from the model (!) and there are some glaring experimental discrepancies, particularly around the vacuum catastrophe [1]. We know that the combination of QM and relativity gives a hybridized model that cannot work at all scales but explains things like the color of gold [2], so we know that there ought to be a single unified model which does work at all scales and has the same explanatory power.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Map%E2%80%93territory_relation

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_constant_problem

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativistic_quantum_chemistry

Re:All models are wrong, but some are completely wrong by Jabbles on Sunday April 05, 2020 @03:17PM (#22787783)
Some predictions of Quantum Electrodynamics have been verified to within 1 part in 100,000,000.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precision_tests_of_QED

However, we know it cannot be completely accurate, as it has no way of explaining gravity.

Re:All models are wrong, but some are completely wrong by tomrod on Sunday April 05, 2020 @02:46PM (#22787508)
I keep this distinction in mind:

- Models are deliberate simplifications of reality, in order to guide thinking and otherwise pull in only important information

- Formulations (formalizations) are encapsulation of principles into a mathematical framework

While there is significant overlap, the two categories do not overlap 100%. I see formalizations of physics as the latter, and we use the former to help keep our understanding of the latter clear.

Re:All models are wrong, but some are completely wrong by carapace on Sunday April 05, 2020 @03:26PM (#22787862)
The Standard Model has no known contradictions in the real world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Model

In "QED" Feynman states that the predictions are as precise as being able to measure the distance between (points in) New York and Los Angeles accurately to within the width of a human hair.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/QED:_The_Strange_Theory_of_Lig...

Re:All models are wrong, but some are completely wrong by magicalhippo on Monday April 06, 2020 @07:37AM (#22792790)
Neutrino oscillation[1] is a contradiction of the Standard model as-is, no?

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutrino_oscillation

Re:All models are wrong, but some are completely wrong by carapace on Tuesday April 07, 2020 @12:05PM (#22804453)
Dunno. (IANAPhysicist) But that's hella cool. Cheers!