Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More
by anamax on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @04:24PM
(#2277256)
> Your example of 10/400 v 10/100 implies early specialisation if that's to be a realistic scenario, which I confess I'm not a great fan of.
Young kids have interests. They change over time, but they have interests.
> Early specialisation forces pupils to close off options before they may realistically be ready to.
You assume too much.
> I believe I've illustrated though how school choice as implemented in Britain necessarily impoverishes the schools perceived as poorer
Actually, you've proposed a mechanism. Even if we assume that things always work that way (and they don't), there should be nothing keeping kids at those poorer schools, so what's the problem?
Young kids have interests. They change over time, but they have interests.
> Early specialisation forces pupils to close off options before they may realistically be ready to.
You assume too much.
> I believe I've illustrated though how school choice as implemented in Britain necessarily impoverishes the schools perceived as poorer
Actually, you've proposed a mechanism. Even if we assume that things always work that way (and they don't), there should be nothing keeping kids at those poorer schools, so what's the problem?
> Someone's kids have to go there
Why?
If no one wants to go there, why keep it open?
> It is not a panacea though,
Strawman.
> we should be honest in appraising its failings.
We should apply that to all schemes.