Re:How Your Coffee Mug Controls Your Feelings (& What You Ca...
by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @03:42PM
(#2277107)
Still confused and doubtful: how does the camera/person issue relate to the coffee mug/comfy chair? The article (which I was criticising) made extraordinary claims about mind control and inanimate objects.
Even if the interview process you describe was part of the 'science' (not evident from the article we're commenting on) then its not the camera, but the actual person that is responsible for the stress response. Isn't it ludicrous to attribute it to the camera?
Finally, social 'science' is mostly cargo-cult science. There are such inadequate attempts to control variables, so little effort to even understand the variables, that doing statistics appropriate for physics and chemistry are inadequate and wildly misleading.
Even if the interview process you describe was part of the 'science' (not evident from the article we're commenting on) then its not the camera, but the actual person that is responsible for the stress response. Isn't it ludicrous to attribute it to the camera?
Finally, social 'science' is mostly cargo-cult science. There are such inadequate attempts to control variables, so little effort to even understand the variables, that doing statistics appropriate for physics and chemistry are inadequate and wildly misleading.