News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:April Is Canceled by JauntyHatAngle on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @07:11PM (#22754526)
I can't say I agree there. The intent of the website is to motivate people to make the most of what they've got.

Does it work for everyone? No. Of course not.

But a "fuck this"? Why? If it works for people, good, if not, move on. No reason to bring down someone for trying.

Re:April Is Canceled by wpietri on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @07:14PM (#22754554)
The reason is that people should not feel additional pressure to do amazing things right now. If they don't have the energy to learn Cantonese and build an app while their relatives are in ICU, that should be fine.
Re:April Is Canceled by JauntyHatAngle on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @10:38PM (#22755768)
This isn't pressure. It's a motivational post. It's clearly aimed at people feeling down and unmotivated by the current environment.

You'd have to be willfully misinterpreting the intent to think this was aimed at people dealing with personal loss.

Re:April Is Canceled by wpietri on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @11:11PM (#22755911)
You really think pressure to do something and motivation to do something are entirely unrelated?

I get the guy's intent. Some people will like and be excited by this. Some people will feel sad and guilty. But even if he only had the first group in mind, he's addressing the whole world. The reaction from ecopoesis is a valid one, because it's not the message he needs. Where we aim doesn't matter as much as what we hit.

Re:April Is Canceled by JauntyHatAngle on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @11:59PM (#22756077)
I think the pressure is non existent unless you somehow believe this webpage is aimed at people going through serious personal torment and/or turmoil rather than an equally large (or larger) number of people who are cooped up trying to adapt their daily life.

It would take some serious self righteousness to take this as a message to the former.

The issue I had with the response was the direct attack on the author's intent e.g. "fuck this".

There are plenty of other comments that state their disagreement or why it didn't land with them without taking it to the level of shutting down the op.

I don't understand the need to diminish the attempt at a potentially helpful mindset. It's helpful to some, pointless for others.

Re:April Is Canceled by wpietri on Thursday April 02, 2020 @12:35AM (#22756238)
It is not just pointless for others. For some, it is harmful.

"Fuck this" is not an attack on the author's intent. it's a valid reaction to how it lands for some readers. If the pressure is nonexistent for you, great! But people other than you are also reading it.