Re:Saudi Arabia ripped off my open-source app and published ...
by mhdhejazi on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:37PM
(#22752744)
I published the app under the GPL-3 license, and with a clear statement that says "It's not allowed to publish, distribute the app, or use it in a commercial way".
They neither respected the license nor the other conditions.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Saudi Arabia ripped off my open-source app and published ...
by skissane on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:01PM
(#22752971)
The GPL3 license allows people to "publish, distribute the app, or use it in a commercial way" (provided that they comply with the other GPL3 conditions, of course). So, when you say it is under GPL3, then say people can't do something which GPL3 allows, you are contradicting yourself.
If you release something under self-contradictory licensing terms, and then people use it in a way you didn't expect – maybe the problem was with your self-contradictory licensing?
Re:Saudi Arabia ripped off my open-source app and published ...
by applecrazy on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:22PM
(#22753142)
If I understand GPL3 correctly, they still have to make the modified source available and state the changes they made. The header on GH that parses the license also seems to agree with me: https://github.com/mhdhejazi/CoronaTracker/blob/master/LICEN...
Re:Saudi Arabia ripped off my open-source app and published ...
by mhdhejazi on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:21PM
(#22753131)
I see your point here. Maybe I should have modified the license itself and stated that's it's a custom license. But they are still not complying with any of the GPL-3 conditions.
Re:Saudi Arabia ripped off my open-source app and published ...
by alain94040 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:49PM
(#22752865)
You can't quite do that. The LICENSE file you put on Git is GPL-3. It's not compatible with the restrictions you are asking for.
And it's not clear that the copy is used in a commercial way. If the app is free, maybe they follow your full conditions?
Re:Saudi Arabia ripped off my open-source app and published ...
by lukeschlather on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:19PM
(#22753114)
You can charge money for a GPLv3 app. But you have to provide source code and the tools to build and run your own version of the app to anyone who buys it.
Re:Saudi Arabia ripped off my open-source app and published ...
by hncensorsnonpc on Thursday April 02, 2020 @12:47PM
(#22760923)
Somebody else said it already. Your "no commercial use" comment is silly and void by making it GPLv3. You cannot have it both ways. You have your point about tivoisation or appstore incompatibility, remove that silly comment from the readme.