Re:Zoom meetings aren’t end-to-end encrypted, despite marketing
by michaelt on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:54AM
(#22738773)
> how are you doing this exactly? a 50 way diffie-hellman that renegotiates every time a user leaves or joins?
By doing whatever Signal and Whatsapp do to support 50-person encrypted group chats.
> you have managed to double your egress
Not at all.
Firstly, the whole point of having two streams is to accommodate viewers with different bandwidth requirements, so the second stream will be a fraction the size of the first. If I'm already uploading HD video at 5 Mbps, and I start also sending an SD stream at 1 Mbps, my egress has risen by only 20%.
Secondly, the h264 spec provides for 'Scalable Video Coding' [1] where a high quality stream can have a lower quality 'subset bitstream' allowing a high-quality video to be converted to low quality by selectively dropping packets. So your egress might not rise by even 20%! Although this h264 feature is less widely used, potentially raising engineering costs.
By doing whatever Signal and Whatsapp do to support 50-person encrypted group chats.
> you have managed to double your egress
Not at all.
Firstly, the whole point of having two streams is to accommodate viewers with different bandwidth requirements, so the second stream will be a fraction the size of the first. If I'm already uploading HD video at 5 Mbps, and I start also sending an SD stream at 1 Mbps, my egress has risen by only 20%.
Secondly, the h264 spec provides for 'Scalable Video Coding' [1] where a high quality stream can have a lower quality 'subset bitstream' allowing a high-quality video to be converted to low quality by selectively dropping packets. So your egress might not rise by even 20%! Although this h264 feature is less widely used, potentially raising engineering costs.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scalable_Video_Coding