News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by roelschroeven on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @09:08AM (#22737106)
That large number of divisors was the reason for the Babylonians to use base-60, I've always been thaught. I always assumed the the 360 degree circle was a consequence of that, but this article contradicts that.

Actually I don't think the article does a great job proving its thesis ("In school we learn there are 360 degrees in a circle, but where did the 360 come from? When it is pointed out that the Babylonians counted to base-60, rather than base-10 as we do, people often ask if there is a connection. The short answer is no.").

The article's conclusion is "So, although angles come from the Greeks, the 360 degrees comes from Babylonian astronomy". And it explains, more-or-less, how the Babylonians came to use 360 degrees for astronomy: because they had a habit of dividing things into 12 part, subdivided in 30. But that doesn't preclude they choose 12 and 30 (instead of, say, 13 and 28) because both are divisors of their base number 60.

Wikipedia points in that direction (but admits no-one really knows):

"Some ancient calendars, such as the Persian calendar, used 360 days for a year.[citation needed] The use of a calendar with 360 days may be related to the use of sexagesimal numbers."

"Another theory is that the Babylonians subdivided the circle using the angle of an equilateral triangle as the basic unit and further subdivided the latter into 60 parts following their sexagesimal numeric system.[7][8] The earliest trigonometry, used by the Babylonian astronomers and their Greek successors, was based on chords of a circle. A chord of length equal to the radius made a natural base quantity. One sixtieth of this, using their standard sexagesimal divisions, was a degree."

Another Wikipedia-quote agrees with your point of view:

"Another motivation for choosing the number 360 may have been that it is readily divisible: 360 has 24 divisors,[note 1] making it one of only 7 numbers such that no number less than twice as much has more divisors" "

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by toasterlovin on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:49AM (#22738038)
> That large number of divisors was the reason for the Babylonians to use base-60, I've always been thaught.

I believe the Babylonians actually use base 12, with the number 60 merely being a convenient multiple of 12. And I think the reason their counting system is base 12 is not because of its greater divisibility, but due instead to the way they used their fingers for counting. So, in the West, we count using each of our fingers and that’s how we arrive at a base 10 counting system. But in certain parts of the world, they use one thumb to count the separate segments of the fingers on the same hand. There are three segments in each of the 4 fingers, for a total of 12 (hence the base 12). And then the five fingers of the opposite hand are used to count how many groups of 12 have been counted. So 5 fingers on the second hand multiplied by 12 finger segments on the first hand = 60 in total.

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by im3w1l on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @09:51AM (#22737498)
An arc-minute is a 60th of a degree. And an arc-second is a 60th of an arc-minute. This strongly points to a base-60 origin imo.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by gumby on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:14AM (#22737693)
The minute ("small part") and second ("even smaller part") come from the era of clockmaking as they were pointless when your timekeeping resolution was crude.* We are quite lucky that hours and then minutes were divided into 60 sections rather than 10, 12, or 100. This may have come from the system you describe (arc minutes, seconds, thirds, etc) which is much older.

* or not just crude but completely different; e.g. Babylonian and Roman hours varied in length each day as the time from sunrise to sunset was divided into twelve equal sections and sunset to sunrise implicitly the same. IIRC the constant-duration hour goes back only to marine navigation a few hundred years ago

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @10:47AM (#22738007)
> We are quite lucky that hours and then minutes were divided into 60 sections rather than 10, 12, or 100.

So let's say there's 20 hours a day, since presumably we'd still want to have two daily clock rotations. Those hours could then be divided into 100 "minutes" with 100 "seconds" each.

If I'm doing my math right, this would mean:

• 1 alternate-universe hour = 1.2 current-universe hours

• 1 alternate-universe minute = 0.72 current-universe minutes

• 1 alternate-universe second = 0.432 current-universe seconds

I could very much deal with this. Current-universe seconds are a bit too long for the level of precision I want with that unit, and I don't think the < 30% change in the length of a minute or hour would matter much once I adapted. And, as a consequence, unit conversions would become so much easier!

I don't think we're lucky at all. :(

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by gumby on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:09AM (#22738236)
Going to base 10 is a step backwards because 10 has so few factors. The meter would have been massively easier to use had it been base 12 or 60.

Perhaps you can get the Mars colonists to adopt a different system. The martian day is just close enough to the terrestrial day to make adapting the terrestrial system for it quite annoying.

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by roelschroeven on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @11:26AM (#22738421)
> Going to base 10 is a step backwards because 10 has so few factors. The meter would have been massively easier to use had it been base 12 or 60.

Only when you also use that same base for everything else too. The decimal system works so well because it uses the same base as the number system we use (almost) everywhere.

And actually I don't really think the lack of divisors is really a problem in base 10. It may be different if you're used to imperial units, but when using the decimal system you don't think in fractions all that much. You either use more places after the decimal point, or move to a smaller unit.

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by gumby on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @03:35PM (#22741547)
Well at the time the meter was designed, base 12 was quite common for money and measurement.

I have lived in an Imperial system country, the modified version used in the USA, and multiple metric countries as well as using a mixture of cgs (SI) and mks depending on what work or study I was doing and still, for customary activity, find a dozen the most convenient. When doing science it doesn’t matter.

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by dr_dshiv on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @12:45PM (#22739449)
If you just keep 10 hour days, then each metric second is .84 of a standard second. Pretty nice.

However, we'd no longer have the nice 1:10 ratio between seconds and human alpha waves...

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by Wowfunhappy on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @05:15PM (#22742667)
I feel like 2.4 hours is too long to be a useful measurement though.

Consider: You're asleep for ~ 1/3 of the day (hopefully), so you'd only have 7 units of time for everything you do while awake. This means many more events would have end up with weird start times, (e.g. 9:68 rather than 9:00 am). Just about every movie would be less than a single hour long.

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by gumby on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @07:18PM (#22743835)
Quibi is a video service launching soon that thinks that movies should be less than 10 minutes. And wasn’t vine’s limit about 4?

The most expensive-per-minute cost/minute videos on TV are ads and nowadays the are all a minute long Or less. And most manage to fit in a problem, a little character development, a happy resolution & climax, and then even a little denouement!

Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by herodotus on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @09:17AM (#22737189)
I think 30 comes from the Synodic month - the time from first crescent to first crescent of the moon, which varies between 29.18 and 29.93 days. There of 12 of these months within a year (and a few days left over).
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by twodave on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @09:48AM (#22737474)
I think it more likely that both the 360-day year and the base-60 numbering system came from a common ancestor (the Babylonian's study of astronomy). Perhaps they just took the lunar year and "rounded" it to correspond more consistently with their view of the stars, which put them on the path to both things.
Re:Full Circle: The complicated history of why there are 360... by simiones on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @01:30PM (#22739984)
The (approximately) 360-day year is a property of nature (the ratio between the Earth's revolution speed and the Earth's rotation speed is approximately 360 if expressed in base 10). It is a discovered number, not invented/chosen.

It is possible that the base-60 numbering comes from this basic astronomical observation, or they may be mostly unrelated.