Rough times ahead for many, sadly.
I am enjoying spending less money to eat but restaurants will not be able to reduce price to meet the lesser demand because their rents will not go down any time soon. The current restaurants will have to fail and that property will have to sit for potentially years before rent is reduced.
We need a penalty (additional property tax?) on vacant real estate to drive prices back down with shifting demand.
I’m personally aware of several small businesses that are simply burning capital from family or friends to stay alive. Almost all of it goes to rent.
I've really noticed it in our trash and recycling bins. They've been half full on garbage day since the quarantine. Usually we have more than we can put in them. I'm hoping this behavior sticks for us, but I kind of doubt it.
Presumably all of those bill are owed to other businesses, who are run by people. People with empathy. People who realize that keep a good customer is better than losing them, even if it means cutting them a break.
I think people will surprise others with how this pain will spread through the entire supply chain so it does't kill any one business. I think all the businesses in the supply chain know that killing everyone at the end of the chain isn't a good idea.
Are we willing to trust our collective empathy or do we need the social contract to fill in the gaps for collective protection from this harm?
I believe many will benefit from empathy, but it will be disproportionate and many communities who will need it the most will not receive it.
I'm just saying we don't have any prior experience to guess as to how much it will or won't recover.
What you’re saying makes sense only if these lockdowns are very short.
What percentage of the U.S. population can actually afford to eat out every night?
Median U.S. household income is about $62K.[1] If you spend only $15 a night eating out, that amounts to $105/week or $5460/year, which is a good chunk of the median household's income, and an even bigger chunk of their income after paying for rent, utilities, taxes and other necessities.
[1] In 2018. Source: https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2019/09/us-median-hou...
So before all this, quite a lot of people dined out a lot.
My guess is that most of those meals are people going out for lunch while they're working, and most of those people are grabbing a sandwich and bringing it back to their desks, which generates no income for waiters.
By that time every restaurant will have had all its fresh food expire and will need to predict when the demand for it will return. If they do not do this accurately, they risk wasted capital that they'll need for when the demand does come back.
They'll have had to been paying rent or mortgage on the property they currently occupy, with only the revenue they're able to make on take outs.
Depending on the structure, I predict most restaurants won't survive this. Any restaurant with a dining room is toast. The world will look different after the crisis.
The world will look different after the first of the very next month.
Everyone keeps assuming landlords aren't people. If you own a commercial building with say six storefronts, once the SIP lifts, you have two choices:
Demand immediate back rent from all your tenants and then evict them all, leaving a completely empty building, or work with them so they can remain open and at least give you partial rent for a while until they can pay you back.
Yes, the government will need to step in and declare mortgages were on hold and no back payment is necessary, but that's already in the works.
I think landlords are smart enough not to just evict everyone as soon as they can. They know that no one will come and take that spot.
It's better to have partial rent than none at all.
And this is the happy choice! Existing businesses will be saddled with the debt of operating through the crisis. New businesses without that debt will have an advantage.
When bankruptcy is logistically more advantageous than debt service, bankruptcy naturally follows.
The world will look different after the crisis.
Well, a totally naive model would be a uniform prior bounded between 0 and 1. The blog post says that they think it'll be between 0.1 and 0.4. That's more narrow than the naive model, but it's still pretty large error bars. I don't think they have spoken with much more certainty than is justified.
They're also very much away of these various factors, but know better than to assume there will be major pent up demand with an economic shock of this nature.
These jobs are not temporarily suspended unless the government intervenes on the scale that European governments are. They will be lost, leaving scars on the economy. No one will be willing to endure this again, when needed again in the future, if they have to sacrifice everything all over again.
Most of the demand shortfall we're going to experience in the coming months will come from people being out of work, not from their being quarantined. That doesn't create pent up consumption that can unleashed at a later point in time.
Nice caveat!
It will come down to the collective confidence.
Confidence to lend people money, to employ people, to spend money instead of overpaying on the mortgage to reduce the chance of default.
If there is a recession it will be a self-fulfilling prophecy.
I don’t think there is any model that can predict pent up demand.
I know a lot of my friends who still have jobs are talking about going out every night when the quarantine lifts so they don’t have to cook.
If a lot of people do that, we’ll suddenly need a lot of waiters back. And then they’ll have money.
Or maybe everyone will have learned that they love cooking at home and never go out again.
I don’t think there is any way to tell. We don’t have any good prior data.
All the previous models assumed unemployment claims and stock market drops when it was possible for everyone to work.
Right now there are a lot of jobs that are temporarily suspended skewing the numbers.