That is a falicy. Because we got something you notice it, but you have no idea what we missed because we were focused on what we got instead of something else. Maybe we would get smart phones sooner in some other alternative universe, we don't know.
If the money spent on space and military was spent on genetic engineering we might not have smart phones, but we would have fire breathing dragons!
Yes - Army had impact on development. War - didnt. Even if we discuss research caused by wars i am 100% sure these would be made a lots faster without an actual war.
And also - its natural army attracts some bright minds because sometimes only army has resources and money to fund research. So as long as it is used for good cause it makes sense as a symbiosis
> First link when searching for DARPA inventions:
The article only mentiones in passing - ARPA, as it was called back then - that DARPA was once ARPA, and doesn't explore how DARPA's rate of invention tanked after the passage of the Mansfield Amendment.
This is a longer story that's relevant to the war is great for research! claim.
Smartphones have given millions of people access to information they would never have. Smartphones are the sum of 30 years of computer R&D, making them cheap enough that Kenya has more then 80% of there population online [1]
The issues you listed would take significantly more time then “five years” to cure.
I think there is room to argue how defense money is distributed and used.
[0] First link when searching for DARPA inventions: https://www.itpro.co.uk/technology/34730/10-amazing-darpa-in...
[1] https://www.standardmedia.co.ke/business/article/2001273507/...