Its about what is paid. The United States has non-discriminatory laws in place where healthcare providers can’t charge two groups different pricing. So what happens is hospitals and such charge insurance 100k for a service, and then discount it down to 20k. The cost of the service is reported as 100k, but the paid amount is 20k.
Because of this individuals are forced to pay 100k if they don’t have insurance. Or if they don’t negotiate a rate on healthcare. This creates an environment where individuals feel they MUST have health insurance. Because of that health insurance companies are treated like they’re essential and can’t fail.
It’s all a fake fucking sham. None of this is necessary.
The insurance company side of this pissing contest is "nobody forces hospitals to list insane prices, certainly not us, but we can give you the leverage to make sure they don't stick -- good luck managing that on your own!"
The issue is that in the US the health insurers do way more than risk pooling. They also do gatekeeping, discounting, & provisioning. Plus there is an asinine indirection layer where their customers are employers instead of the covered.
In a properly functioning health market there would be a very important role for insurance, our current market is just so insane it’s hard to see it.
Collective plans, like those provided by your employer, would risk-pool, but then should we really attribute the pooling to insurance companies?
So yes? We should give credit to insurance for providing value in the real world.
I agree that we should give insurance companies credit for the value they accidentally create in the world that we live in -- so long as we keep in mind that the value creation was predicated on their inability to find & leverage information.
However, going forward in a world of increasingly available information, do you think it is a good idea to rely on their inability to find & leverage information? I sure don't.
They are the central agents of information discovery and we all reap the benefits of the massive amount effort they put into those activities.
If anything I think we should be endeavoring to make health insurance more like traditional insurance to provide those efficiencies more broadly
Of course, each head of the hydra points at the other two and claims it isn't the problem.