News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Genetic Architecture of Gray Matter by perl4ever on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:47PM (#22715713)
You might have heard that correlation isn't causation? It's a very common statement, that people think they know the meaning of. But the way it is always used is, this correlation isn't causation, because I don't like it, and that correlation is causation, because I do like it. In other words, special pleading.

If something is not causative, which you seem to acknowledge in your example of "gene X", then why exactly do you attribute a correlation to something other than coincidence? What is coincidence, anyway? Einstein said coincidence is literally the only thing anyone ever experiences, in a literal mathematical/physical sense.

Re:Genetic Architecture of Gray Matter by twomoretime on Sunday March 29, 2020 @12:10AM (#22716333)
Well if you consider all the entropy in the universe, our particular microstate is an indescribably rare coincidence...

It's a matter of probability. Each if the following, individually, you'll agree, is rather probably correct:

1. Genes control brain structure 2. Brain structure controls predisposition toward cognitive macrostates (we classify them as pathologies) 3. Macrostates like BPD, ADHD, and Autism are proxies for specific behavioral tendencies 4. Genes are heritable

Why this has taken so long to discern is the noise from 30-70% environmental influence. Point being there's far more than correlation here, there's a direct known mechanism.

Re:Genetic Architecture of Gray Matter by perl4ever on Sunday March 29, 2020 @10:21AM (#22719188)
Do you think there is "a gene" for being an asshole on the internet? Is there an instruction, or a group of instructions, responsible for a computer game being terrible? Can we learn anything useful from the THERAC-25 disaster by studying which instructions were linked to it in order to stop using software that has those instructions?

Talking about separating the noise or environmental influence is "not even wrong".

Re:Genetic Architecture of Gray Matter by twomoretime on Sunday March 29, 2020 @11:10AM (#22719606)
>Do you think there is "a gene" for being an asshole on the internet?

Well of course, there are multiple such genes that predispose people toward being "assholes" on the internet. One could argue that autism related genes increase the odds that a person will be called an asshole online.

>Is there an instruction, or a group of instructions, responsible for a computer game being terrible

Well you're kind of stretching with this analogy here...code doesn't sexually reproduce and lines of code don't typically have such global and complex functions.

>Talking about separating the noise or environmental influence is "not even wrong".

That's a little ridiculous, isn't it? Are you saying there's no reason to study the relationship between behavior and genes because there's too much noise? Is that something you think is true or something you want to be true?

Because OP literally proves you wrong...

Re:Genetic Architecture of Gray Matter by perl4ever on Sunday March 29, 2020 @12:06PM (#22720052)
"Are you saying there's no reason to study the relationship between behavior and genes because there's too much noise"

No, I'm trying really hard to express the idea that the question of whether there is/is not too much noise is a completely meaningless, wrongheaded question to ask.

If you did the analysis on a computer game that sucked, maybe you find that GPU related code was correlated? Does that mean less GPU code = less suckage?

You didn't respond to the THERAC-25 comment, which may have been the most targeted one to what I'm trying to communicate.

What do you think is "proven wrong"?