News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by chipperyman573 on Saturday March 28, 2020 @08:01PM (#22715249)
It's been a long time since I took calc. What does the second derivative show us?
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by lsb on Saturday March 28, 2020 @08:13PM (#22715298)
Acceleration.

The rate of change of the rate of change of deaths.

The word exponential only occurs once in the paper, and the rate of change of an exponential is an exponential, so take as many derivatives as you want and it's still going up. Why they don't take the log of deaths over time isn't explained.

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by dpwm on Saturday March 28, 2020 @08:58PM (#22715504)
I've seen very little coverage that really uses the term exponential in a way that suggests those reporting know the implications of that. I've seen one plot with a logarithmic y-axis, and that was in the Guardian some time ago. From it, it appeared a crude heuristic could be drawn that from the point that lockdown is implemented, the cumulative deaths appear to grow between two and three orders of magnitude.

I've been grabbing the data put out by Johns Hopkins [0] for the last few days to update some plots in a very hacky Jupyter notebook.

Crucially, the plots are normalized to (estimated) populations and the y-scale is logarithmic. I've put them on github in case anyone else is interested [1].

[0] https://github.com/CSSEGISandData/COVID-19

[1] https://github.com/dpwm/covid19-analysis/blob/master/Coronav...

edit: Clarified that though exponential growth is widely used, the implications of that are not followed up. It's past my bedtime!

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by grandmczeb on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:45PM (#22715694)
> I've seen one plot with a logarithmic y-axis, and that was in the Guardian some time ago.

You mean like the widely cited NYT Coronavirus death tracker[1]?

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/21/upshot/corona...

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by mr_toad on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:01PM (#22715523)
Even fewer people understand logarithms than exponential growth. If you publish graphs with a log scale you will certainly confuse some people into thinking that the illness is tapering off.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by dboreham on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:02PM (#22715524)
Hmm...I see the term exponential everywhere, but based on comments I read on public Facebook posts, almost nobody in the general public has any clue what it means or implies. But this site is widely referenced. It has a log scale option: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by babesh on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:42PM (#22715684)
It's not an exponential. It's a shifted sigmoid.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by the8472 on Saturday March 28, 2020 @11:32PM (#22716147)
The logistic function specifically, which is a blend of an exponential growth and an exponential asymptote. So initially it behaves indistinguishably from an exponential function, until you get close to the inflection point.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by dnautics on Saturday March 28, 2020 @11:49PM (#22716217)
No it's not the logistic function. Sigmoid is a general term of the shape, logistic specifically refers to an equation that's almost certainly not correct. It's probably close to stretched exponential, which is a reasonable approximation of the curve of an autocatalytic process that is controlled by stochastic collisions that can self-exhaust, but even that's not exactly correct.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by 3solarmasses on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:13PM (#22715566)
yep. My first thought was why the hell they didn't they use the word acceleration for better readability.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by analog31 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @10:47AM (#22719424)
As others have mentioned, acceleration, or the rate at which the rate is changing. Now... I admit to being an armchair epidemiologist. I've been graphing the data from the JHU website myself, but I've just been using semi-log plots. This is an option at some of the "dashboard" sites.

In a semi-log plot (vertical axis is logarithmic), a constant rate of exponential growth is seen as a straight line, the slope of the line is proportional to the doubling rate, and changes in that slope show that the exponential growth rate is changing. This is a way to "eyeball" the graphs without trying to read anything too profound into them. But just comparing the graphs of the US, Italy, and South Korea is interesting.

What I'm not doing is publishing conclusions from this armchair analysis.

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by dboreham on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:00PM (#22715516)
Rate of change of rate of change.

They explain this in the paper: a constant (flat line across the graph) would correspond to exponential growth. The actual graphs drop (mostly), indicating sub-exponential growth, which is a good thing.

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by zeroimpl on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:20PM (#22715590)
A constant 2nd-derivative means quadratic growth, not exponential.

I'm bit confused by the graphs, because they show the 2nd-derivative going to 0. But to stop this thing, we actually need to decelerate, eg going negative on the 2nd-derivative.

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by dpwm on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:31PM (#22715635)
I think they're talking about the 2nd-derivative of the cumulative deaths. As they can (presumably) only increase, the first derivative is >= 0. The second derivative tends to zero as the cumulative deaths flattens off.

Edit: Now that I think about this some more, you're right. There has to be a decrease in the daily cases, which implies a negative 2nd-derivative. They mention "relative 2nd-derivative." It seems to be defined in the paper in a way that leaves me more confused:

> Daily fatality rates from the included countries were then used to calculate estimates of the relative second derivative of total deaths, N, 1/N d²N/dt², for a period of at least ten days.

Does this mean they are taking the second derivative of the reciprocal of the cumulative deaths?

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Sunday March 29, 2020 @02:02AM (#22716787)
They are taking the 2nd derivative of total deaths and dividing that by the number of total deaths and calling it the relative second derivative (rate of increase of rate of increase of total deaths, relative to total deaths).
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Sunday March 29, 2020 @02:31AM (#22716870)
> A constant 2nd-derivative means quadratic growth, not exponential.

A constant relative second derivative of total deaths is what they are talking about, meaning that they are flattening the 2nd derivative of the exponential by dividing by the exponential, making it constant.

Of course, this is all numerical methods, not analytical methods, so it doesn’t necessarily make pure analytical sense that they are even talking about an exponential.

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Saturday March 28, 2020 @09:33PM (#22715647)
The only way the velocity (number of cases) would go negative is if they discovered a disproportionate number of false positives or (number of deaths) if deaths were discovered to be due to something else [or people came back to life]. As time goes on, the velocity will reach a constant of 0, presumably. The acceleration at a constant velocity is 0.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by zeroimpl on Saturday March 28, 2020 @10:35PM (#22715905)
Eventually acceleration would go to 0, but it needs to go negative first. Right now acceleration is positive and velocity is positive, hopefully soon acceleration will become negative, then eventually velocity will approach 0 from above and acceleration will approach 0 from below.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by 9wzYQbTYsAIc on Sunday March 29, 2020 @02:10AM (#22716805)
I believe that you are correct in your calculation, but incorrect in your assumption.

You are treating the curve of daily deaths as the thing to be differentiated. They are treating the curve of total deaths as the thing to be differentiated.

While the curve of daily deaths certainly would have a negative acceleration, the curve of total deaths is monotonically non-decreasing and therefore the second derivative is always positive but trending towards zero.

Like I mentioned above, the only way for total deaths to decrease (making the function not monotonically increasing and therefore capable of having a negative acceleration) would be through errors of accounting.

Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by dralley on Sunday March 29, 2020 @01:07AM (#22716592)
The goal was never to "stop" Coronavirus. Just slow it down enough that it doesn't crush the medical system.
Re:An international comparison of the second derivative of C... by fortran77 on Sunday March 29, 2020 @01:12AM (#22716610)
1st: Velocity

2nd: Acceleration

3rd: Jerk

4th: Jounce