Re:The New York Times Releases Its Dataset of U.S. Confirmed...
by SpicyLemonZest on Friday March 27, 2020 @11:25AM
(#22703608)
That just doesn't seem like a fair standard. Why should only experts in a relevant field talk about the coronavirus? Nobody tries to stop people from sharing hospital stories from their friend's cousin's boyfriend who's a nurse.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The New York Times Releases Its Dataset of U.S. Confirmed...
by throwawayjava on Friday March 27, 2020 @11:29AM
(#22703666)
Oh, I think it's completely fine to play with the data and talk about it with friends.
But SEOd medium posts have different reach potential than a facebook comment/phone call with friends/family. That's kind of the whole point of them.
Re:The New York Times Releases Its Dataset of U.S. Confirmed...
by SpicyLemonZest on Friday March 27, 2020 @11:34AM
(#22703737)
I get what you're saying, but I don't consider the two things separate magisteria. I don't think there's anything generally wrong with people trying to spread honest ideas they've had, even if they aren't experts.
Re:The New York Times Releases Its Dataset of U.S. Confirmed...
by ghostpepper on Friday March 27, 2020 @12:02PM
(#22704050)
For something like Covid, I'd question how much time should be spent on "trying to spread" vs the amount of time spent on refining the idea.
Re:The New York Times Releases Its Dataset of U.S. Confirmed...
by Uehreka on Friday March 27, 2020 @11:59AM
(#22704008)
One thing about experts is that they’ve usually made it through the Dunning-Kruger “confidence pit” and come out the other side. They’re often cautious about making very strident remarks, and when they are really confident in a conclusion, it’s usually because it has a very high probability of being correct. When someone new to a field comes to a contrarian conclusion, they’re often willing to show more confidence in their conclusion because of the Dunning-Kruger effect. This makes it hard to take non-experts at their word, since they’re often unaware of how likely they are to be wrong.
Now, if a total non-expert had come out of nowhere with an analysis that contradicted the public health establishment, definitively showed that the danger was massively overblown, and was right, that would be one thing. But this medium post was incorrect in its conclusion, quite confident in its conclusion, and advised courses of action that would put many people in danger (such as reopening schools).
Re:The New York Times Releases Its Dataset of U.S. Confirmed...
by SpicyLemonZest on Friday March 27, 2020 @12:07PM
(#22704094)
I'm not sure which medium post you're referring to here. I'm sure people do sometimes write incorrect advice on Medium that would be dangerous if followed, but experts can do the same thing. Remember when the WHO said not to ban travel?
I'm also not sure that distinguishes the case I mentioned. It might also cause problems to assume some particular anecdote is true and representative.
Re:The New York Times Releases Its Dataset of U.S. Confirmed...
by thu2111 on Saturday March 28, 2020 @11:13AM
(#22711597)
That's a very romanticised view of expertise that doesn't match what is seen in the real world. If your view were true the replication crisis would not be happening, but it's barely even got started.