News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by checoivan on Monday February 28, 2011 @12:38AM (#2270185)
Laptops are officially only for managers and Program managers. As a dev/test you can get a loaner for a presentation or find one, somehow.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by sriramk on Monday February 28, 2011 @12:59AM (#2270244)
5-year Microsoftie here (mostly PM, some dev)

Sorry - I don't think that's true. When I was a dev I had a laptop. It is highly dependent on the team you work for. I know a lot of devs who have laptops. In fact, most things hardware related are highly related to the team you work for. Since MSFT works on such a variety of things, hardware needs tends to vary dramatically

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by paulcam on Monday February 28, 2011 @05:27AM (#2270802)
9 year softie here (Shell Test in my early days, now doing Dev work)

Indeed everything is dependent on need. PMs always get laptops because they spend lots of time outside of their office. On my team, most dev leads are also issued laptops. Friends of mine in teams closer to laptop features (think Windows 7 touch input, for example) never have had problems getting a laptop. On my current team, it's not common for an IC dev to have a laptop. It's also not common to find an IC dev with a machine more than 8 months old. I haven't quite figured out what everyone else's fascination is with laptops. I bought one for my own personal use, brought it to work, and then stopped bringing it because it just sat on my desk doing nothing 95% of the time. The other 5% I've replaced with post-it notes which, I'm happy to say, are available to both PM and Dev.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by plinkplonk on Monday February 28, 2011 @12:41AM (#2270192)
"Laptops are officially only for managers and Program managers."

Heh! That's what I thought :-p Not surprised to hear MS works that way :-). Funny way to economise, making laptops status symbols. I think Google gives devs nice laptops and is probably better off for it.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by nostrademons on Monday February 28, 2011 @12:57AM (#2270235)
The number of hours of work-from-home that Google gets out of those laptops more than justifies their cost. Hell, I'm posting this from my work laptop, taking a break from writing out a whole bunch of use cases and product design decisions.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by alexgartrell on Monday February 28, 2011 @02:25AM (#2270453)
Facebook is laptop-only[0], though I've not yet started [1] I imagine they have something similar in mind.

[0] Plus an external monitor.

[1] And from what I've read on HN, I probably won't, as they're going out of business any day now :P

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by lovskogen on Monday February 28, 2011 @02:21AM (#2270445)
What do you do over at Google?
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by nostrademons on Monday February 28, 2011 @04:51AM (#2270736)
Very broadly, Search Features. I worked on the visual redesign that launched last May, and before that some of the search tools (particularly Wonder Wheel and Related Searches) and a bit on the move from having separate search properties (books.google.com, blogs.google.com, video.google.com, etc.) to a single search app. Then I spent about 6 months doing some infrastructure stuff with the webserver, and I'm now doing some feature work that's in the early stages of the project.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by lovskogen on Monday February 28, 2011 @01:30PM (#2272237)
Cool. What tools do you use for daily design? I've been slowly moving from Photoshop to CSS, and want to start using stuff like Antetype early in the process. I've also figured out that Photoshop is good for finalizing a design that's been moved around, tested and iterated upon.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by rsbaskin on Monday February 28, 2011 @12:48AM (#2270211)
It's not really a status symbol. PMs tend to be more mobile, presenting in meetings and such, and need laptops. Devs and testers get much better desktops.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by plinkplonk on Monday February 28, 2011 @12:52AM (#2270223)
"It's not really a status symbol."

A status symbol is, by definition, something only or mostly upper echelons of a hierarchy can get, with fig leaf justifications about why the folks on the lower rungs are "not worthy" of them. The surest way to make anything (a private office, a parking space, a laptop) a status symbol is to mandate that only people above a certain level in the hierarchy can get one.(Note that I am responding to a comment that states that laptops are only for managers and devs have to get "loaners". Other people at MS seem to disagree that this is the case)

"Devs and testers get much better desktops."

Good desktops aren't an excuse for not having good laptops.

The association of laptops with presentations and meetings conveys a lot about MS's approach to development. No wonder the place is infested with multiple layers of redundant management. I wonder how MS Research fares? Do Peyton Jones and co go laptopless too?

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by DaveMebs on Monday February 28, 2011 @01:44AM (#2270373)
Everything done at MSFT is based upon dev-test-pm triads where all members of the team have equal say in the product and decisions. This is true from the individual contributor level up to the VP level (where it starts to break down). Dev's report to dev leads, test to test leads, and PMs to PM leads. All PMs, including individual contributors, get laptops. They are the same level as developers, and more importantly, in a completely different hierarchy.

I'm not going to lie and say devs don't want laptops - of course they do. Everyone wants a free laptop. But guess what? I'm a PM at MSFT, and you know what I want? A second desktop and better monitors. Are these a status symbols for devs? No. Resources are fairly assigned based on need, and everyone at the company realizes that.

I should also point out that most senior devs do have laptops in my experience. It's the really new, junior guys that don't get them right away. There are communal resources if a dev really needs portability for a few days.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by plinkplonk on Monday February 28, 2011 @02:08AM (#2270423)
"I'm a PM at MSFT, and you know what I want? A second desktop and better monitors."

If you want them to do your job and you are not getting them, that just illustrates the point better. Economizing on hardware (and paper towels, heh!) is really dumb for a software/tech company.

"I should also point out that most senior devs do have laptops in my experience. It's the really new, junior guys that don't get them right away."

So, in other words a laptop is a status symbol. Junior devs rank lower in the hierarchy though they use the same tools and work on the same codebases as senior devs.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by JanezStupar on Monday February 28, 2011 @05:13AM (#2270778)
So what you're saying is that where you work everybody has 2 desktops, 2 laptops and nobody would raise a brow if you wanted another?

In my book what Microsoft does is waaaaay beyond "trying to save on toilet paper". The last place I worked having a monitor bigger than 19" was a status simbol.

Excuse my patronizing - you are around/under 25 right? Because I have noticed that juniors tend to have this petty fascination with hardware that goes away with time (myself included).

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by plinkplonk on Monday February 28, 2011 @05:25AM (#2270798)
"what you're saying is that where you work everybody has 2 desktops, 2 laptops and nobody would raise a brow if you wanted another?"

I work on a 3000 node super computing cluster doing heavy duty Machine Learning and signal processing and a lot of funky (and classified) hardware, and yes, no one would blink if I wanted two more machines (or a 100 more) - as a matter of fact we recently did a million$ + upgrade of the hardware on my say so, so yeah everyone on this project gets all the hardware they want ;-)

Looking around I see (my personal system, doing mostly rendering and reports) 7 quad core machines, three 27 in monitors, 2 laptops, both Thinkpads. I (literally) only have to ask to get more machines.

"Excuse my patronizing - you are around/under 25 right?"

Patronizing is always inexcusable and rude, and snark appropriate on reddit isnot so valued on HN, but I don't mind at all. When you say things like that you just make a fool of yourself in public, go right ahead. :-)

And as for my age, I am closer to 40 than 25, so perhaps you just need to try again? ;-)

EDIT: (btw "paper towels" != "toilet paper". You missed the reference This which wrt the benefits cuts in 2004which included stopping towel supply(later rescinded) - I confess I am only guessing the towels were paper. ;-)

from mini msft (I heard from a friend in MS, but mini is an online reference)

"Should have just done the towels and called it a day!" - Lisa Brummel, May 18th 2006.

You know, one moment of reflection: the circle is now complete. My second post to this blog was on July 6th, 2004. It was right after an impromptu employee meeting with Ballmer and Gates and as part of that, Mr. Ballmer justified the unfortunate recent benefit cuts, the main two points of ire being the towels and the ESPP revamp. Now, two years later, we're getting our towels back.

Has it always just been about the towels?

(Possible book title flashes through my mind.)

It's not like we're sweaty work-out animals always in need of a shower and fresh towel. No. What riled us was the bone-headed way the towel cut-back was handled, explained, and justified. It truly made us wonder just who are these people in charge and just who do they think they are leading? The towels became the symbol of poor leadership. That and the office-supply hide-and-seek.

Someone should send Ms. Brummel a golden towel award. I'd like my old ESPP back, too."

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by paulcam on Monday February 28, 2011 @06:12AM (#2270880)
Just a slight correction: the towels mentioned here aren't paper towels, but real actual towels. Many MSFT buildings have showers stocked with towels. At one point, the towel service was discontinued as a cost-saving measure. Lots of employees took issue with this and wanted their towels back.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by kenjackson on Monday February 28, 2011 @09:48AM (#2271341)
That sounds very cost ineffective. I'd be more productive with a personal helicopter with landing pads in various locations with an oncall pilot... but the productivity benefit is probably not worth the cost.

All organizations need to be cost efficient... unless you're a govt agency or contractor. In which case being cost INefficient is actually rational.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by plinkplonk on Monday February 28, 2011 @10:37AM (#2271530)
"That sounds very cost ineffective."

What specifically sounds "cost ineffective"?

3000 node clusters? That is a tiny cluster as clusters go. 7 quad core machines? Two ThinkPads? A million dollars on one-of-a-kind hardware?

You my friend, have zero clue in this. Since you have no idea what the specific cost benefit analysis on this project is that statement is built on nothing but your prejudices. I grant that it may "sound" ineffective to someone with no experience working on such projects. If I were to blather about whether a drug development proposal (something about which I know next to nothing) is "cost effective" without even looking at the financial documentation, I'd come close to what you are doing with that statement.

"I'd be more productive with a personal helicopter with landing pads in various locations with an oncall pilot"

In the right situation, expensing a personal helicopter would be trivial. What is "cost effective" depends on the derived benefit. Applies to startups too. The cost depends on the benefit derived not on what the raw materials cost.

So (fwiw, I could care less about convincing you) It is not really "cost ineffective". Machine/networking etc costs on this project are trivial compared to the total budget (spent on other resources) and (much) more importantly the derived benefit.

(just making up an example since I can't talk about what this project really does) If you were able to decrypt, and classify (in the Machine Learning sense) all enemy communication in real time, how much is that capability worth to a nation? Worth spending a few millions on? Not every project in the world has the financial structure of two guys in a garage coding up the next silly web app.

Iow you are talking about "unknown unknowns" with nothing to back up your conclusions. Amusing but not really relevant.

[deleted]
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by plinkplonk on Monday February 28, 2011 @11:02AM (#2271626)
I see you are making up scenarios where people randomly order new hardware and that too every two weeks just for the hell of it. My assumption is that we are all professionals who won't do crazy things like that on our employer's dime and are talking of what hardware we require to do our jobs well. nostrademons's reply above provides a good justification for a laptop, for example.

No I can't justify helicopters (which was something you injected into the conversation). But I can justify some bandwidth on a satellite, say, and a few other things. Whatever it takes to do my job well. And I can also imagine some jobs ( a general in charge of an invasion say), where the cost of a helicopter on call would be so small in the overall context as to be non noticeable. The point is "cost effective" is always in reference to the overall context.

"you clearly don't work in the same space as virtually anyone here, much less a company like Microsoft."

I never said I did. And in my gp post I was responding to a sneering question as to whether (specifically) I could justify an extra machine or two where (specifically) I work.

I quote "So what you're saying is that where you work everybody has 2 desktops, 2 laptops and nobody would raise a brow if you wanted another?"

Guess what? That's right. Nobody would twitch an eyebrow let alone raise it.

Now wrt Microsoft specifically, even if MS were to give every single developer an extra laptop it cost much less than one of their VPs takes home as an annual bonus for doing nothing in particular. If Google can give their devs a MacBook Pro MS certainly can. (well, not a MacBook maybe but a top of the range Windown laptop). Without blinking.

"how much is that capability worth to a nation?

A fair bit of money. Although you clearly don't do that, otherwise you wouldn't even suggest it on HN. :-)"

Yeah that was a made up example. I explicitly identified it as such. I was just trying to demonstrate that what is "cost effective" depends on what you are trying to do. 1 $ maybe too much money. Or a million dollars may be a drop in the bucket. It all depends.

I do work on similar(ly ambitious) projects. Hardware is (so) not the bottleneck we have. " everyone on this project gets all the hardware they want" just happens to be the truth. Just append " that is needed to do their jobs well". I thought that wouldn't need to be explicitly stated here on HN, but whatever.

(And I am done with this thread. Too deep. should have triggered my cutoff alarm). Apologies to the rest of the folk on HN. Mea Culpa for getting irritated with a (perceived) sneer.

I am disgusted with myself for responding to obvious baiting and will leave the thread here (vs deleting it) as a monument to my folly.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by nostrademons on Monday February 28, 2011 @05:31AM (#2270810)
My personal setup is 3 24" monitors, 2 quad-core desktops, and a ThinkPad laptop, backed up by a few tens of thousands of machines sitting off in a datacenter somewhere. With what they're paying me, they could afford my total hardware setup with less than a month of salary, and it's saved me far more time than that. I use basically all of it - all 3 monitors are usually covered with windows, and it's not unusual to have 4-6 webservers running on my desktops.

I'm older than 25, though probably not as old as plinkplonk.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by jdp23 on Monday February 28, 2011 @10:15AM (#2271455)
Exactly. Unless a company's in such bad shape that they have to nickel-and-dime on expenses, the value of productive (and happy!) employees far outweighs hardware costs.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by JanezStupar on Tuesday March 01, 2011 @05:49AM (#2274928)
See nobody is disputing what all of us claim here.

But it's the usual perception of majority of companies that engineering, product development,... are cost centers and cost centers need to be minimized to gain profit.

It's what you get when you let the beancounters run the business. But people bitching here that developers at MS don't have it well off - are being ignorant about majority of industry where developers are still being under-utilized to everyones dismay.

And Microsoft's care of intellectual workers is top tier. Even the ones that are not well off (sitting in a room with 10 other people) are better off than 90% of our industry.

Indeed some people get to have anything they want or need - good for them. Even better if it makes the end result better. It's good that they don't get into situation as I have in multiple occasions - running a top priority, code red development effort which if fails it will take the company down, and then when I needed a new virtual appliance I got informed that I cannot get is since the ESX is out of harddrives and that there will be no purchases since the budged has already been spent.

And this is the industry standard - not the "I run bazillion node supercluster".

Hell where I used to work - two of the interns went and bought 2 24" monitors each out of their own money to use them at work.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by paulcam on Monday February 28, 2011 @05:30AM (#2270807)
> It's the really new, junior guys that don't get them right away.

I've been at MSFT for 9 years and have yet to be issued a laptop. I've been MSFT for 9 years and have yet to actually need a laptop. :)

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by Duff on Monday February 28, 2011 @11:32AM (#2271718)
Sounds like the dev types get 3-4 monitors and very beefy PCs, and work 40 hour weeks.

Why would you want/need a laptop in that case? Multi-monitors with a laptop is asking for ergonomic-related health problems.

Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by Locke1689 on Monday February 28, 2011 @12:49AM (#2270217)
Laptops are, for the most part, neither necessary nor useful. Most developing/testing work is done in a single place, so I never really had a problem.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by dmnd on Monday February 28, 2011 @01:08AM (#2270272)
It's very team dependent. Every dev in Bing has their own laptop. Of course most of us don't have our own office, it's more common to be doubled up.
Re:Working at Microsoft – Day to Day Coding by kprobst on Monday February 28, 2011 @02:21PM (#2272453)
I remember being at the MS Redmond campus for an MVP summit shortly before .NET was released (ca. 2000). Some of the devs in the VB.Net team would amble in to participate in discussions and whatnot (it was very informal). Most of them had laptops and did email and even coding while they were in the conference room.

Again, this was 10 years ago or so, but I'd expect that developers can still get a laptop if they want to.

Personally I've always preferred a desktop machine to code, because a laptop means I can take work home.