Re:The ‘Blurred Lines’ case scared songwriters, but its time...
by WalterBright on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:14PM
(#22697456)
You can already do "fair use" of text under a certain amount, and the world hasn't ended.
> a hundred hours
This is the Labor Theory of Value, which is discredited. The value of something is not necessarily related at all to how much labor was put into it. The value of something is what someone else is freely willing to pay for it.
Nobody has ever asked me how many hours I put into X. They couldn't care less. It has nothing whatsoever to do with the value of what I created.
Re:The ‘Blurred Lines’ case scared songwriters, but its time...
by WalterBright on Friday March 27, 2020 @02:13AM
(#22700747)
> crucial pieces of engineering
That's what patents are for, not copyrights.
I'm sorry, and would like to know how to put it another way to not sound aggressive, but this point is absurd[1].
Length (in this case runtime) of the resulting product has little to no relation to the amount of work or value put into it and its development[2].
1- I'm not even sure why'd you use code as an example, because it is the easiest counterexample to your point. Hundred-line programs can be trivial exercises or crucial pieces of engineering that make or break entire products or businesses (if code should or not be copyrightable is another discussion).
2 - Somehow this discussion also reminds of the time a bureaucrat asked me why I was taking twenty hours to 'read a paper' when it was only a few pages long. I told him it likely took the authors a hundred hours to write six pages rather than sixteen so I could read it in twenty hours instead of two hundred.