News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by mmaunder on Thursday March 26, 2020 @02:39PM (#22696500)
They predicted us traveling by rocket much quicker across the globe. I see this mentioned now and then with disappointment that the one thing close to a rocket - the Concorde - was discontinued.

But what happened in the aerospace industry is that we instead focused on fuel efficiency and lower noise, which lead to the high bypass turbofan engine.

Instead of accelerating a small amount of air to supersonic speeds, which is both extremely noisy and fuel inefficient, we moved to a system that takes that small amount of air and uses it to drive a much larger fan which then takes a large volume of air and accelerates it to subsonic speeds. That's why 'jet engines' of the old days were much thinner and noisier than the really fat engines we have today.

This led to much cheaper and quieter air travel. This is a huge benefit - just not quite as spectacularly "space age" as the sci fi authors of the 1950s envisioned.

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by martythemaniak on Thursday March 26, 2020 @02:51PM (#22696618)
That might not be too far away - SpaceX does want to use their Starship to fly point-to-point across the globe. I suspect the noise, will make it infeasible for all but a few major destinations. They'd likely have to have a sea-based platform 20-30km away from the city, then use a floating tunnel with Tesla/BoringCo pods the rest of the way to actually get downtown.

Still, it would be pretty sweet. Go downtown, check in, take a 10 minute pod ride, get strapped into your seat (there's no washrooms, or moving around), blast off and 45 minutes later you're on the other side of the world, another 10 minute pod ride away from downtown.

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by hoorayimhelping on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:45PM (#22698316)
As anyone who lived in Central Florida or the Space Coast in the 80s and 90s can tell you, sonic booms from hypersonic objects returning from orbit are no joke. It's worth putting up with once or twice a year when you know the space shuttle is returning from orbiting the planet. But I imagine most people would be pretty annoyed with constant sonic booms from rich people traveling across the globe.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by sneak on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:40PM (#22697751)
> I suspect the noise, will make it infeasible for all but a few major destinations.

I think the issue will be more geopolitical than anything. Few national defense organizations will trust an ICBM heading toward "just next to (no seriously, it's fine)" one of their largest population centers, even if it is from someone they consider friendly.

Not insurmountable, but definitely an uphill battle.

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by derekp7 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:28PM (#22698179)
And yet they are perfectly content with thousands of inbound jet planes flying into all their major cities. Which could just as easily have any payload they want.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by sneak on Friday March 27, 2020 @07:09AM (#22701899)
I have a feeling that if any of those planes were going Mach 30 they would feel a little differently about it.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by derefr on Friday March 27, 2020 @01:41PM (#22704974)
Would planes really need to go Mach 30 to devastate a city? 9/11 could have been about planes with nukes on them.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by njarboe on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:33PM (#22698220)
Or trucks.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:42PM (#22698290)
Or - in some areas at least - ships.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by 3pt14159 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @07:05PM (#22698899)
Naw, this is what intelligence is for. It's not like these launch points aren't known in advance. Is Russia really going to lack awareness of a launch from a common civilian launch point? Plus they could always have court mandated blackout periods. World tensions heating up? Shut down landing points to anywhere 100km of Russia or you get fined.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by potiuper on Thursday March 26, 2020 @07:34PM (#22699107)
MIRV throws a wrench into any "intelligence" along with a sub sitting next to that "civilian" launch point
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by 3pt14159 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @07:38PM (#22699131)
I'm fully aware of MIRV and a number of other issues related to arms control. I'm not concerned about governments thinking a ICBM is incoming because it shows up on a radar. We have plenty of technical and social solutions to this. Nations do not just nuke a single city out of the blue.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by jacobwilliamroy on Thursday March 26, 2020 @07:46PM (#22699172)
9/11 but with Rockets this time.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by the8472 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:45PM (#22697800)
How would you avoid the TSA? Or the urge of people to arrive early lest they miss their prepaid flight and have to pay rebooking fees? I doubt it's economical to just schedule those rockets no matter how many passengers take them.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by bananabreakfast on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:57PM (#22697920)
What TSA? How exactly is someone going to hijack an autonomous rocket?
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by the8472 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:53PM (#22698370)
They just might blow it up as it's coming down over a city.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by catalogia on Thursday March 26, 2020 @06:09PM (#22698486)
The TSA makes people take off their shoes, but in the rest of the world that doesn't typically happen. Somehow, there aren't loads of shoebombs blowing up planes in Europe.

The TSA don't do anything constructive. It's a jobs program justified through fear mongering. The supposed threat they guard against is a million times rarer than lightning.

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by the8472 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @06:43PM (#22698733)
I don't disagree, but whatever official arguments the TSA has for existing would also apply to intercontinental missles regularly launched from american spaceports.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by outside1234 on Thursday March 26, 2020 @06:43PM (#22698731)
You forgot climate concerns. We can't be adding to the problem with even more inefficient methods of getting places.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by gok on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:59PM (#22697317)
High bypass turbofans can be used for supersonic transport, as can even more sophisticated efficiency wins, like geared turbofans. SST was killed by noise regulations in North America, which in turn were largely protectionism that Boeing demanded because their own SST project was a failure. It's not a coincidence that somehow no other country in the world had problems being overflow by supersonic jets.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by bluGill on Thursday March 26, 2020 @06:27PM (#22698623)
India and Malaysia both banned over flights because of noise. It wasn't just Boeing.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by cwmma on Thursday March 26, 2020 @02:48PM (#22696589)
Charles Stross wrote a whole thing on why we point to point rockets weren't a thing that would work

https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2015/01/why-wer...

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by martythemaniak on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:02PM (#22696718)
Let me try to break it down:

1. Expensive. For sure, it inherently uses a lot more energy. There's not going to be an economy class on these and they'll never replace jets en masse.

2. Security. Not really. He talks about hijacking/terrorism, but these things won't have pilots or free movement on board. Everybody's going to be strapped into their seat for 45 minutes to withstand the forces and the rocket's gonna do all the flying.

3. Spaceports. See my sibling comment, these will have to be build on water far away from cities.

4. Inconvenient. No, these will be massively convenient if you can afford them. It takes 90 minutes to complete an orbit around the earth, so any two points will be at most 45 minutes away. Spending a bit over an 1hr flying New York-Sydney downtown-to-downtown is incomparable to the slog that exists today.

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by outworlder on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:55PM (#22697895)
> Security. Not really. He talks about hijacking/terrorism, but these things won't have pilots or free movement on board. Everybody's going to be strapped into their seat for 45 minutes to withstand the forces and the rocket's gonna do all the flying.

Superpowers already have the capability to intercept things that travel faster and are smaller than these.

> It takes 90 minutes to complete an orbit around the earth

Except these are suborbital. And 90 minutes is for a full orbit around ISS altitudes. For most routes, it would be around 30 minutes (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqE-ultsWt0)

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by FlyMoreRockets on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:57PM (#22697297)
> 2. Security. Not really. He talks about hijacking/terrorism, but these things won't have pilots or free movement on board. Everybody's going to be strapped into their seat for 45 minutes to withstand the forces and the rocket's gonna do all the flying.

It isn't just the cabin that is a potential terror threat, but a huge part of the supply chain and operations/management.

If these are built on water, a distance from land, it should be possible to construct a nearby floating rectenna to crack and cryocool hydrogen and oxygen for propellant via beamed energy from a solar sat. Granted, there is a fair bit of infrastructure requirement, but with interest rates so low, compounding interest isn't a big deal, like it was in the original SPS calculations.

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by outworlder on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:47PM (#22697818)
> If these are built on water, a distance from land, it should be possible to construct a nearby floating rectenna to crack and cryocool hydrogen and oxygen for propellant via beamed energy from a solar sat.

That's such an enormous undertaking that it dwarfs the rockets themselves.

SpaceX, which is the only company that's even close to achieving this, prefers kerolox.

So what threat are we trying to mitigate? Liquid oxygen is not very problematic. We transport large amounts of the stuff on roads with no issue. Kerosene is used everywhere.

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by njarboe on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:38PM (#22698262)
The Raptor engine for SpaceX's next rocket that would do these orbital/sub-orbital flights is fueled by liquid methane and LOX. A better fuel in many ways and much easier to make on Mars.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by outworlder on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:48PM (#22697828)
That piece is talking about suborbital Spaceplanes

I agree with the article. But we may have suborbital rockets. Which are much more feasible.

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by mdorazio on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:22PM (#22697570)
I would argue that the market demanded lower cost travel rather than higher speed, so the technical development followed suit. Fuel efficiency and lower cruising speeds were simply a result of that demand.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by verelo on Thursday March 26, 2020 @05:43PM (#22698301)
Also by looking at the raw number of flights to accidents, its probably the most dangerous plane ever invented. We also optimized for safety.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by elevenoh on Thursday March 26, 2020 @10:03PM (#22699919)
>This led to much cheaper and quieter air travel. This is a huge benefit - just not quite as spectacularly "space age" as the sci fi authors of the 1950s envisioned.

A moral here: align tech predictions w/ what most people want, don't assuming a kind of linear progression in advancement?

Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by jdsully on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:35PM (#22697061)
At cruising speed the Concorde was as efficient as a commercial jetliner of the day. The issue was they had to be subsonic near land due to noise and in that mode of operation they were extremely inefficient.
Re:Miracles You’ll See in the Next Fifty Years (1950) by outworlder on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:43PM (#22697781)
Almost(not quite) as efficient as a 747 or business jet. On a per-passenger basis, it was vastly less efficient.

But that's the Concorde. That's not the upper bound on what physics allows.