News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 26, 2020 @09:40AM (#22693445)
It's just the consequence of market economy. Everyone is under pressure to "cut out fat", make themselves "lean". That applies everywhere across the supply chain. First thing that goes is every redundancy, buffer and spare capacity - things that would mitigate a crisis like this. It's because the companies that "cut out fat" can grow faster, sell cheaper and profit more, compared to their competitors that have risk horizons longer than few months.

What needs to be done is legally mandated buffers and redundancies (so that no one can gain a competitive advantage by omitting or removing them). Many countries had that after II World War. Unfortunately, out of the wood works came people screaming "efficiency!" and cut it all out.

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by kirykl on Thursday March 26, 2020 @11:46AM (#22694704)
The government does have stockpiles for emergencies, mandated buffers will guarantee overproduction and affect market equilibrium
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 26, 2020 @12:05PM (#22694964)
> The government does have stockpiles for emergencies

As you can see now, it doesn't. Neither does any other government.

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by ImaCake on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:59PM (#22697320)
Well, they do. But they were just way to small.
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:22PM (#22697569)
They used to be bigger. Now they're Lean, and exist for the sake of ticking a checkbox.
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by cvlasdkv on Thursday March 26, 2020 @04:35PM (#22697701)
Privatization and "efficiency" on all things of national interest do that. It is why deficit hawks are misleading their constituents with every sentence.
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by kirykl on Thursday March 26, 2020 @08:06PM (#22699273)
Your hatred of lean is confusing, Companies exist to make money why would they hold extra inventory ?
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by minikites on Friday March 27, 2020 @08:10AM (#22702202)
Companies are merely one part of society. Why does society exist?
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by kirykl on Friday March 27, 2020 @10:33AM (#22703120)
Huh? What does that even mean? I'm replying specifically to the notion that lean manufacturing is a bad thing
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by minikites on Friday March 27, 2020 @10:41AM (#22703166)
You're saying companies exist to make money but an isolated factoid like that doesn't make for a productive discussion. Lean manufacturing may be good for individual corporations but it's clearly bad for society and society needs to continue existing for corporations to exist.
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by kirykl on Friday March 27, 2020 @02:28PM (#22705413)
Tying up $ in assets that are sitting in warehouses instead of using that $ elsewhere is a not benefit to society. One premise of lean is to match variation in demand to supply as quickly as possible, you should be calling for capacity to scale production and lower lead time, not hold inventory. You might not even hold the right inventory.
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by TeMPOraL on Friday March 27, 2020 @04:51PM (#22706756)
> Tying up $ in assets that are sitting in warehouses instead of using that $ elsewhere is a not benefit to society

As we can clearly see now.

> One premise of lean is to match variation in demand to supply as quickly as possible

This is done at a cost of making the whole system less resilient against demand spikes and in-chain disruptions. A perfectly lean system would be following predicted demand precisely, maximizing efficiency at each stage, and as a result break down as soon as anything in the chain changes by even most tiny amount.

I'm a layman in supply chain space, but my observation is that the risk horizons on the market are too small - anything that happens less frequently than once every few quarters may as well not exist. So throw in a big enough wrench, and everything is in shambles for way longer than the existence of initial cause (see the so-called "bullwhip effect", or as it's known in control theory, a positive feedback loop making the system oscillating and unstable). It could've been helped if there was enough buffer in the system to allow time for expanding manufacturing capacity.

As for what to do with different kinds of inventory, two observation. One, the earlier you are in the manufacturing process, the more potential buyers for your product you'll have - so it's that less risky to keep inventory. It's probably not worth it to stock too much of front left doors to 2020 BMWs, but a sheet metal wholesaler doesn't have to run lean and choke everyone downstream when the foundries or miners get disrupted by an epidemic. Two, for some stuff it's really the role of the government to keep buffers. PPE and food would be this. Imagine if any of the Western countries actually had a proper (Cold War style) stock of PPE for a pandemic, and food for everyone for a year. There wouldn't be any worry about staple shortages or hemorrhaging medical staff. There wouldn't be a problem with PPE manufacturers expanding capacity either, as the government could just buy enough goods to fill in the entire buffer capacity they plan on depleting - which would give the manufacturers a chance to recoup their investment in meeting a temporary demand surge.

Bottomline: not saying that fat is good, but I think there's such a thing as being too lean, and that is the problem we're having.

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by minikites on Friday March 27, 2020 @02:50PM (#22705625)
>capacity to scale production and lower lead time

How has that been working out? What happens when factory employees fall ill?

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by kirykl on Friday March 27, 2020 @04:01PM (#22706268)
What happens when your inventory runs out ?
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by TeMPOraL on Friday March 27, 2020 @04:54PM (#22706786)
Potentially the same problem, except you shift it forward in time. So perhaps the factory staff can recover and get back to work before the buffer runs out. Or competitors can ramp up production in time to compensate. Point is, a buffer is adding inertia into the system, an integrating block, which is often a good thing, as it eats oscillations. It's essentially the same reason you put capacitors next to the power supply in electronics - they eat voltage spikes, preventing your device from shutting off just because it briefly drew more power.
Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by zaroth on Thursday March 26, 2020 @10:33AM (#22693922)
Have you considered what the cost of adding these “mandated buffers and redundancies” to the overall economy? Have you attempted to integrate these costs over time when there isn’t a pandemic going on, and made any attempt to determine the net effect?

Have you considered that you can’t start a small business with buffers and redundancies? And that small business accounts for 50% of overall employment?

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by tonyhb on Thursday March 26, 2020 @11:18AM (#22694368)
Yes. His point is that game theory and economic principles favour the leaner, therefore every company moves to max. efficiency with JIT supply chains and max leverage.

The only way around this is regulation if we want to be able to withstand crises _without_ bailouts.

That's currently not the situation, which is why bailouts happen.

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by chrisjc on Thursday March 26, 2020 @02:50PM (#22696611)
Agree with you completely, but how can we regulate domestically and expect companies to survive when the external competition doesn't have to abide by the same kinds of regulations.

Edit: the obvious answer is tariffs, etc... but we haven't seen any real action like this until recently

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by zaroth on Thursday March 26, 2020 @03:45PM (#22697174)
It’s not just game theory, it’s actual real world efficiency. Which translates into jobs and salaries. Reducing baseline capital efficiency drives up all baseline costs. These costs are passed on to consumers and act as a drag on the economy.

It would make no sense to do that in response to a black swan event.

Let’s say small business has to keep 6 months of expenses in reserve instead of the typical 3 months rule of thumb. For the same amount of cash on hand that means you can afford half the monthly expenses.

It’s not just a matter of “hoard more cash”. That cash had to come from prior quarter’s net income. Revenue you don’t invest drags down growth (a.k.a hiring). Revenue you don’t spend is also taxed, adding further drag on the business.

Basically what this proposal is suggesting is to drastically reduce the “money multiplier”. This shrinks GDP.

If the government forces your company to shut down for weeks, I expect them to pay for it. It doesn’t make any sense for small businesses to self-insure against government mandated shutdowns. That would simply be a recipe for destroying small business.

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by tonyhb on Friday March 27, 2020 @12:09PM (#22704111)
Nope, the efficiency is captured as profit only until other efficient competitors appear and lower the price.

The price does _not_ "trickle down" to consumers or employees until it has to. Again, theory: why would a company give away free money?

Re:3.28M file for U.S. jobless benefits by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 26, 2020 @12:08PM (#22694996)
> Have you attempted to integrate these costs over time when there isn’t a pandemic going on, and made any attempt to determine the net effect?

No, I didn't. I'd actually like to - because it isn't obvious to me that the result would come in favor of minimizing the buffers. Consider that buffers in the supply chain only cost as much as the storage costs. Which may run well into billions over time, sure. But this pandemic has already erased trillions of dollars in the last three weeks, and it isn't showing any sign of stopping any time soon.