Re:Dgit: Git with decentralized remotes
by asdkhadsj on Wednesday March 25, 2020 @02:33PM
(#22687177)
I too am confused.
My immediate thought was that Dgit offered a centralized remote, packaged around decentralized technology. Which is to say, many people have a main "master"; a single, centralized repo/branch. Dgit might be offering the same thing, but hosted in a decentralized fashion. I could see the value in this for backup, I suppose.
Sure, Git is decentralized but many of us still prefer having some centralization. Bundling that up into a decentralized system (aka no third party host) has some value.
Though really to me if I was avoiding Github/Gitlab/etc, the primary value add I'd want to see is all of the Github/Gitlab UI features. Notably pull requests, code reviews, comments, basic issue tracking, etc.
Conceptually, Github is not different for the local ".git" folder sitting on my machine. I can do `git clone '../some/local/dir/.git" just as easily as I can with any SSH or HTTPS link: the underlying protocol used for the transaction changes but the concept does not. So I think defining a "remote" as something inherently centralised by definition just because Github et al are popular isn't helpful: it simply persists the misconception.
Basically: I'm still actually struggling to really fully understand what dgit is.
git-ssb is a protocol for accessing git repos stored in an ssb-db (which is a distributed db). git-ssb-web is a web UI for exposing git repositories stored in an ssb-db.
Can you explain dgit in those terms?