Re:The field of “useful reals” between rational and real num...
by pdonis on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @06:20PM
(#22679712)
> If countability is important to you, you should change the rules so that the property that the field is closed w.r.t limits of Cauchy sequences does not make your set uncountable.
Ok, fine: I hereby declare that the set Q of rationals is a closed field, because I define "closed" to mean "closed under Cauchy sequences whose limit points are rational numbers".
Does that seem OK to you?
Re:The field of “useful reals” between rational and real num...
by klodolph on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @06:09PM
(#22679605)
> Redefining the rules if something does not work is how you do mathematics works all the time:
Exploring the consequences of alternative definitions is fantastic, let’s do more of that.
Redefining the terms that somebody else uses in a conversation sucks royally. Everybody hates it when people do that. Don’t be that guy.
Rather: If countability is important to you, you should change the rules so that the property that the field is closed w.r.t limits of Cauchy sequences does not make your set uncountable.
Redefining the rules if something does not work is how you do mathematics works all the time:
- A PDE does not have a solution in a classical sense and you hate this? No problem: You invent the theory of weak solutions and distributions and simply change the concept what is to be considered a solution of the PDE.
- The concept of algebraic varieties turns out to be to limiting to obey the rules that you would love them to have? No problem: You define the concept of algebraic schemes and now talk about algebraic schemes instead of varieties (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Scheme_(mathemati...).
TLDR: Mathematics is often the art of "defining your problems away".