Re:Man dies after self-medicating with chloroquine
by pbreit on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:50AM
(#22672062)
One died.
I am not extremely confident in what is not even a conclusion. I am simply shocked at the pushback and resistance to a promising treatment with minimal downsides.
Medecine appears to be the only profession in the world that only accepts one form of evidence. That is what is maddening.
Re:Man dies after self-medicating with chloroquine
by gus_massa on Monday March 23, 2020 @11:01PM
(#22671462)
I agree. Nitpicking: I think only 1 person in the treatment group died. It is not clear that the 3 that were transferred to the ICU finally died. (And 1 just left the hospital and 1 had too much nausea with the drugs, I hope that at least they are fine.)
I take it you are not familiar with epidemiology, clinical evaluation of drug efficacy, or medical statistics. That’s fine! No one is saying you need to be. But you shouldn’t be extremely confident of your conclusions when experts are telling you that you’re wrong.
The French chloroquine+azithromycin trial was terrible and no one in the medical world believes it. There’s a reason no respectable journal would publish it. SIX of the people in the C+A arm died and were removed from the analysis, which is absurd. The outcome was viral titers, which were different for different arms. Just maddening.