News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whoa... Groupon Generated $760M in Revenue in 2010 by alanfalcon on Saturday February 26, 2011 @02:46AM (#2265119)
Yes, that is considered Revenue.
Re:Whoa... Groupon Generated $760M in Revenue in 2010 by hncommenter13 on Saturday February 26, 2011 @05:05AM (#2265238)
I disagree. I believe Groupon should call this $760M number gross revenue, with recognizable net revenue being somewhat lower. (I'm not an accountant, but I've had some exposure to these issues.)

One of the key questions in proper revenue recognition is determining whether the company is, in essence, a principal or an agent. eBay, for example, reports net revenue, which is a percentage of its gross merchandise sales, as it only collects transaction fees for arranging exchanges between a buyer and seller.

Groupon keeps a fraction of the total dollars customers send them, with the balance being distributed to the merchant when the customer redeems the coupon.

A good discussion of the accounting standard is here: http://www.revenuerecognition.com/content/experts/9002.asp

In the rather long article linked above, it mentions three indicators that can point to net revenue treatment as the most appropriate, each of which I think applies to Groupon:

a) "The supplier is the primary obligor in the arrangement." In other words, the local merchant is ultimately responsible for delivering the product/service to the customer, not Groupon.

b) "The amount the company earns per transaction is fixed (in dollars or as a percentage of the arrangement fee)." If I spend $100 on a "$25 off $50 deal," Groupon still makes its stated fee/percentage of the purchase price of the Groupon. They don't make anything on the incremental dollars I spent at a restaurant over and above the Groupon amount, for example.

c) "The supplier has credit risk." This may not be directly applicable, but the gist of this indicator is whether it is the merchant or Groupon who is ultimately at risk to collect from the customer for the product/service. My guess is this risk lies with the merchant. (Imagine I use a Groupon for part of the cost of a meal; if I can't pay the balance, it's the restaurant that bears the loss, not Groupon.)

These issues are always a judgment call (accounting is rarely as black and white as one assumes it to be). But to my mind, these factors indicate Groupon should likely call the $760M revenue figure gross, not net.

Re:Whoa... Groupon Generated $760M in Revenue in 2010 by allantyoung on Saturday February 26, 2011 @03:52AM (#2265177)
No, it shouldn't count as revenue. The money owed to merchants is considered a liability and is probably treated as Accounts Payable.
Re:Whoa... Groupon Generated $760M in Revenue in 2010 by michael_dorfman on Saturday February 26, 2011 @07:50AM (#2265421)
Of course it is revenue.

Think about retail for a moment. The amount of money a retailer takes in is revenue. The fact that he needs to pay a wholesaler for the items sold doesn't change that fact.

If the money is being paid to Groupon, it's revenue.

Re:Whoa... Groupon Generated $760M in Revenue in 2010 by _delirium on Saturday February 26, 2011 @09:30AM (#2265583)
In transactional / middle-men businesses, it's more standard to only report your percent take as "revenue", rather than including pass-through dollars (e.g. PayPal only reports their fees as revenue, not all dollars that flow through PayPal). But I suppose it's unclear if Groupon is that kind of business; arguably they could be more like a retailer, where it is standard to include all dollars flowing through as revenue.
Re:Whoa... Groupon Generated $760M in Revenue in 2010 by ahalam on Saturday February 26, 2011 @05:02AM (#2265236)
Agreed. It shouldn't be counted as revenue. It is such misleading reporting that leads to over valuation and bubbles.