I acquired this "skill" about a year ago and now I use it when I suspect there may be filler text or introductions to concepts I already understand. I know it works because I uncannily land on interesting but otherwise nondescript passages. When I scroll back up I find that I did indeed skip the filler. Of course, this isn't voodoo or unprecedented. It's just funny that I've read so much that my brain basically has a regression model for various semantic characteristics that signal novelty by subject area. I suspect I also switch into different modes of scanning based on the writing style detected.
Because of all that, I actually prefer no layering at all. Reuters articles are Layer 1 compressed and I find them annoyingly curt.
I was also thinking about how useful chdaniel's layers would be when it's more practical to just skim.
1. going through pages looking for interesting textual structure, for example dialog, numbers, capitalized words, etc.
2. scanning vertically or in a zig-zag fashion, using peripheral vision to look for interesting words
3. reading the first few words of a paragraph before deciding if it's interesting or not.
I normally use 2, then try 3 on a paragraph that passes 2's test. Only when a paragraph passes test 2 and 3, do I decide to read it with my (temporary) full attention. 1's more for when I'm searching for something in particular or when what I'm reading follows a specific format and I'm interested in a particular section with distinctive structure.
Here is a dictionary definition: "The action of reading something quickly so as to note only the important points." If you showed me that definition before I started skimming effectively, I would have never extrapolated the behavior you described from that word. I didn't even know people did that.
-----------Idea ----------
I could see value in an open source "Verbose Dictionary" where people from all ages and walks of life would be able to add their own definition of a word. There would be two general rules when someone makes an entry:
1. They would need to write their definition in a verbose manner. I'm thinking at least three sentences, usually more, but also not as long as a Wikipedia entry.
2. They would need to be as open and honest as possible, so that there's minimal translation loss between what they're communicating and what we take away from it. Importantly, the word needs to be described with both intellectual and emotional cues. The author would also be able to let the reader know basic facts about themselves, and there would be some mitigations against trolling or fakers.
Over time, we would converge on a more universal language to maximize our mutual understanding of what each of us truly feel and think about words, concepts, current events, people, etc.... There would also be optional tags and slider scales (i.e. 1-10) that can attach to each definition so that you can correctly communicate the breadth, depth, and magnitude of your thoughts and feelings on the word. Critically, the goal would not be to achieve groupthink and converge on the same definition. That would be contrary to the premise of the Verbose Dictionary.
Not only would I find such a dictionary highly captivating, but I also think that it can serve as a useful tool for conceptual mapping or things like artificial neural networks. What are your thoughts? Would you use the Verbose Dictionary?
Isn't that Wikipedia?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skimming_(reading)#Methods_&_P...
> also not as long as a Wikipedia entry.
I don't get the issue. What would this Verbose Dictionary provide that Wikipedia doesn't? You seem to want to differentiate it for no reason.
VD on the other hand would be a real-time, K-clustered map of the human experience. If you go to the entry for Love, you’d see people from all over the world sharing what loves mean to them, anecdotes and all. Crowdsourced feedback would surface the best entries to the top. Political topics would solicit good-faithed micro-blogs with the specific aim of humanizing each other and learning why we believe in what we do. You'd be able to go back in time to see where people's minds and hearts were at on a certain day. Algorithms and strict moderation would ensure that diverse viewpoints are shared and treated in good faith. Maybe I’m wrong, but I think if there’s a dictionary for swearwords, there’s certainly room for a dictionary of the human experience.
Check out the below study published in Nature in 2019. It makes the claim that cultural values of openness are what give rise to democracy, rather than the other way around. We need more of that openness right now. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-019-0769-1
I think the ideal solution will be some sort of middle ground, where much of the drilling down will be done by clicking on specific words or sentences, but a slider would allow you to generally expand more text in the article, for things that aren't exactly related to other sentences.
It does take a bit of doing, and drilling down to another layer should also be able to delete text, so the wording flows better.
If you want to talk about this more, feel free to send me an email, I find this problem very interesting.
Two quick thoughts...
- Maybe limit the layers to 2 or 3. The example you've got in Invision has eight layers which gives me decision paralysis. Do I want the "7 minute read" or the "9 minute read"?
- Consider an onramp from Twitter. People have big audiences there, and linking out to Layered Ink might work better than those 50 tweet "tweet streams".
1. Hmm, the concept is: the more layers, the better. This way, you can easily "pick your pace" — if you're short on time and you want easily-consumable content, you'd skim through 1-min versions. Ideally if at a certain point you say "holy shit, I love this", you'd jump to the full version. The same way you don't just skim your favourite author's new article — you just go to the full version because he's proven time and time again that his style fits you
2. Oh? Tell me more? Did I get you right: showing it to ppl who bypass the 280-char-limit by having tweet storms/threads? P.S: I love Dynasty's logo!!!
How do you expect users to interact or choose between "7 minute version" and "9 minute version"? Are they expected to keep going up the layers one-by-one until the full version is reached? Are they expected to intuitively know which one to pick right away?
Too many possible choices also delegates the responsibility of picking the number of layers to the writer, which can be an additional stress.
If possible, I'd try to figure out the most common use cases. The interactions and thought processes of users should be intuitive and dead simple to describe. Other than, loving the idea! Keep it up. :)
However, I am curious to know what the tool does. In other words, someone can write a “thesis statement”, and the bullet points and an outline and so on in any editor. What does the tool do?
1. Let people brain dump — write everything they've got on their mind. Click "new layer". Cut down on words. Click "new layer". Cut down on words. Repeat ad nauseam.
Every time you write a new layer, you're "editing" your article so as to make it shorter. In other words, you're purifying the idea
2. Let people write the shortest version, then write a bit more, then more.
I'm doing way #1 because I feel like road #2 prevents people from having a brain dump... I'd lose all my ideas if I'd start with the short verison
Brainstorming, well, "everything is a graph", but perhaps picture versions as columns, with each column showing all three levels, with transclusional editing between them. So you do a pass in whichever direction, create a new column, and easily grab material from previous variants, and repeat.
Within a column, editing text in any level, updates that text in any other level it appears in. That's the transclusion. Since all levels are said to have a copy of the most-brief text, if you edit that text at any level, it's updated at all levels of that column.
When you start on your next column/version, you can easily grab text from previous version(s). And you might do that in different styles. If you copy the entire column, then the old column serves as a checkpoint, and the new for continued editing. Or copy just the most-distilled level, and then work downward, to "reconstitute in a more crystalline form". Or copy just the least-distilled level, and work upward, attempting a new distillation.[1] Or do these from a previous column instead of the most recent one. And the old columns/versions are easily accessible, to browse for inspiration, or to grab stuff from.
[1] Hmm... I guess copying just the least-distilled text "forgets" what the embedded more-distilled text regions of it were previously? So one can try playing with the "brain dump" text again, without the distraction of the previous distillation choices. Then when things settle down again, one can highlight "this region is now distillation level n".
For UI, perhaps highlight-drag-n-drop to more distilled levels? And if each level say had an "X" - delete and forget this level, then the different styles of column copying unify as "fully copy a column, and then X-away the levels/region-choices you want to discard"?
So... All levels simultaneously visible, and easily edited together. And multiple versions of them easily accessible, in support of doing multiple exploratory passes, with each pass able to easily draw from past attempts. And working in either direction: towards distillation, or building out from a more distilled seed.
That was the brainstormy vision anyway. I've no idea if it would work out. And for whom - I work in both directions (back and forth), and like a visual record as external memory (so I don't have to remember things or take notes), and like to just see it all (without view switching). Someone who doesn't want those, might find multiple columns to be distracting clutter.
Thanks. The bottom-up journaling style of use [1] looks tempting, even as someone who generally prefer graphs to trees.
PayWhatYouWant[2], but it seems a pity one can't easily play with it non-persistently, without giving them an email? I wonder if that's the right choice, funnel wise, for something with a "I can't imagine using it... oh, that's neat" dynamic.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sT_nlmlbhBE [2] https://gingkoapp.com/p/pricing/
It's essentially the reverse way of what writers do when they write the "tweet version" of their essay — plus all the steps in-between.
@ your last sentence: Check out the InVision link I've added to the OP!
Here's how I see what I described earlier: https://invis.io/GQWINO2YKU2#/410298082_1_Min_Verison
What do you think?
The original motivation were layout considerations for printed newspapers with limited space. With all articles pre-written like that, an editor could arrange them on the final layout and cut off at the end at discretion while keeping the most relevant information given the remaining space.
That being said, I don't think this is too relevant for your idea, just an interesting anecdote.
Here is the demo (use the slider displayed after the first blockquote in the article) https://blog.fgribreau.com/2014/05/fr-stretchtext-retour-sur... or click on "[+]" to go deeper.
The code is open-source here: https://github.com/FGRibreau/stretchtext
You could possibly prototype with a coda template: https://coda.io/@michael-joseph-rosenthal/essayist
Example: a short, by words, explanation for a mathematical problem. Then, the possibility to expand to a more rigorous proof and so on. This would enforce a top/down type of writing that could benefits audience and creators. I believe it would easely apply to the great part of knowledge sharing.
Neat implementation.
Here's how I see what I described earlier: https://invis.io/GQWINO2YKU2#/410298082_1_Min_Verison
What do you think?
[1] https://m.signalvnoise.com/the-writing-class-id-like-to-teac...
Indeed, there are problems with Twitter, people take stuff out of context and like to be polarized. But just as you say, the first time I interacted with Twitter I loved the fact that I had to "distill" my idea.
Kinda like Vodka — you keep distilling alcohol until you purify it (or close to it). What you're saying about "refining the idea" made me think about this.
The problem? Tweets are easier to read than long-form essays, as they require less time commitment. If the content is not good on a long-form article, you'll find out way too late. With this tool I'm developing:
Layer 1 is the shortest version of your essay, the 1 min read — like a tweet. The idea boiled down to the shortest version
Layer 2 is the same text from layer 1, but with extras added here and there. What's already read by you is in black ink. What's new is in blue ink. This is the 2 min read version
Layer 3 shows everything from Layer 1 and 2 in black ink, but what's new is now in blue ink. and you keep doing that until you get to the full version.
I can post some screenshots here of my mockups, as I'm a designer. PM me if you find this intriguing!
——
Edit: Since people are showing interest, here's how I see it happening — https://invis.io/GQWINO2YKU2#/410298082_1_Min_Verison
The first thing that you see is the first layer (1 min version). Go right for 3 and 5 min version!
——
Edit 2: since I'm seeing the upvotes and the emails, I quickly made this sign-up form for the people who want to be updated when the product is done: https://layered-ink.webflow.io/
I would put up the https://layered.ink link but the domain hasn't been propagated yet.
@Admins — please do let me know if this is not permitted so I can take it down. Apologies if so.