Re:CA governor projecting 25.5M COVID19 cases in CA in 8 wee...
by jdminhbg on Thursday March 19, 2020 @11:33PM
(#22634523)
Understandable, but since there's been clarification, I think that should be reflected in the title.
Re:CA governor projecting 25.5M COVID19 cases in CA in 8 wee...
by jader201 on Thursday March 19, 2020 @11:48PM
(#22634649)
I would disagree that the title should be changed, since the linked content does not reflect the additional context you’re referring to.
I suppose a more fully-qualified title might append “in letter to the president”.
But appending “if no measures are taken” is not accurate, since this article — his letter to the president — doesn’t include this context.
Saying the title is sensationalist is equivalent to saying the letter is sensationalist.
And if that is the case, the most you could say is a sensationalist title accurately represents a sensationalist letter.
Re:CA governor projecting 25.5M COVID19 cases in CA in 8 wee...
by jdminhbg on Thursday March 19, 2020 @11:57PM
(#22634712)
Generally the HN style has been to actively editorialize to tone down sensationalism, even if the linked title or content is sensationalist.
Re:CA governor projecting 25.5M COVID19 cases in CA in 8 wee...
by sneak on Friday March 20, 2020 @12:02AM
(#22634744)
I think GP was suggesting that the letter is itself not sensationalist, and thus neither is the title as it accurately reflects the content linked, and thus it is fine as-is.
I agree, it is a reasonable statement and reasonable projection (within an order of magnitude) that reflects the gravity of the situation. A lot of people don’t seem to realize just how big this is about to become.
The title was based on the entirety of the linked content — the letter from the CA governor to the president — which included no context around the numbers being based on no measures being taken.