News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by hnburnsy on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:02PM (#22633119)
From the UK...

'As of 9am on 19 March 2020, 64,621 people have been tested in the UK, of which 61,352 were confirmed negative and 3,269 were confirmed positive. As of 1pm 144 patients in the UK who tested positive for coronavirus (COVID-19) have died.'

So that 5% positive and 0.2% death rate of those tested. Seems likely that they would only be testing the worst cases.

When I see data like this but see estimates in the news of 1-2 million deaths in the US it makes me shake my head.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by greedo on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:12PM (#22633171)
Your numbers are far off. The death rate (CFR) isn't based on the number of people tested, but of people infected. That's currently at 4.4% for the UK. The UK has roughly 68M citizens. If 5% get infected, that's 3.4m cases. Of those, (assuming the current CFR), 150K will die. Additionally, over 600K will require hospitalization for around 2 weeks. The NHS has been stripped of funding for decades, and is in no condition to handle that load.
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by dingaling on Friday March 20, 2020 @04:28AM (#22635983)
> The NHS has been stripped of funding for decades

That's incorrect. The NHS budget has increased constantly:

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/nhs-in-a-nutshell/nhs-...

The problem with the NHS is that it is poorly managed and the money is pissed away on inefficiency

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by hnburnsy on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:54PM (#22633442)
Not my numbers, but why do you and I guess others think 5% will get infected when only 4.4% of the worst cases are testing positive? Wouldn't sampling the random population result in a significantly lower positive rate?
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by zzleeper on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:41PM (#22633714)
"worst cases are testing positive" ?????

Most tests are on healthy people that were close to positive. If the R0 is as high as they say (2-4) then most people (60+%) will get it.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by hnburnsy on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:57PM (#22633805)
Testing Criteria in UK...

----------------

2.1 Patients who meet the following criteria (inpatient definition)

requiring admission to hospital (a hospital practitioner has decided that admission to hospital is required with an expectation that the patient will need to stay at least one night) and

have either clinical or radiological evidence of pneumonia or

acute respiratory distress syndrome or

influenza like illness (fever ≥37.8°C and at least one of the following respiratory symptoms, which must be of acute onset: persistent cough (with or without sputum), hoarseness, nasal discharge or congestion, shortness of breath, sore throat, wheezing, sneezing

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/wuhan-novel-coron...

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by acqq on Friday March 20, 2020 @04:29AM (#22635986)
> Testing Criteria in UK...

And? The specific testing methodology doesn't prove that the speed of new people getting sick and die will change anytime soon without establishing very strong measures, which is the only information that you need to know.

Calculate yourself the speed in any country, not just the UK. See the numbers 6 days ago, see the numbers 3 days ago, see the numbers now. How many days is the doubling time? Three days. What does it mean? The factor of 2 ^ 10 in 30 days: one thousand TIMES more cases needing hospital in four weeks.

Some numbers now show (with big measures introduced!) 4 days. That reduces the factor to around 200 TIMES more cases needing hospital in four weeks.

There aren't that many hospitals in the world.

Nobody can conclude from the available data that it doesn't spread that fast, as it's consistent across many countries and different amount of testing, it can be concluded just that the virus still didn't spread across all the places it could, and that it's an interest of everybody to stop that spread.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by greedo on Thursday March 19, 2020 @11:02PM (#22634275)
You quoted 5%. I was just using your (arguable extremely low) infection rate.
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by acqq on Thursday March 19, 2020 @08:20PM (#22633242)
Look at the statistics of each day:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_t...

In the UK the number of infected doubles every 3 days. The number of dead at the moment doubles every 2 days. Now starting from 3300 infected today, and 144 dead today, calculate the numbers in just one month. If you think that the growth won't continue if nothing is done, compare with the equivalent data from Italy: just 15 days ago, there were

    2020-03-04  3089 infected  107 dead
today:

    2020-03-19  41035 infected  3405 dead
and note that they even tried to do the lockdown first of the critical areas and later of the whole country.
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by hnburnsy on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:13PM (#22633563)
Thanks, do you know the number tested in Italy?
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by acqq on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:42PM (#22633723)
Like I've said, the number of tested is irrelevant for the estimate of the future, as the growth speed is stable across many countries, where the number of tests hugely differ:

  US 37824 tests 11,604 cases 161 dead
  UK 56221 tests  3,269 cases 144 dead
But in all countries the doubling time is also around every 3 days. It's very stable information and allows for easy estimates: 30 days of such doubling makes 10 of them, or the factor 2 ^ 10 = 1024 times more.

Even if the doubling time (for new deaths) increases to 4 days (the number that can now be derived from Italy) the resulting factor in 30 days changes to 2 ^ 7.5 = 181 which still results in almost 30000 deaths in the next month in each of UK and US... as long as something very resolute isn't done to prevent the growth.

But the problem isn't just the dead alone. It's that the number of those that need the hospital treatment is much higher than those that die, and that is when the hospitals aren't overloaded. These numbers are huge. See my other post here for just the number of needed intensive care beds -- those are especially hard to increase.

Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by MikeAmelung on Thursday March 19, 2020 @09:59PM (#22633815)
How are we accounting for the number of deaths being almost the same with the US having almost 4 times as many cases?
Re:Has the Covid-19 response gone too far? by acqq on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:02PM (#22633838)
The factor 4 is also not too important -- with the doubling time of 3 days, it's a difference of only 6 days in one or another direction -- any delays or speedups can easily add up to that. Only the speed of growth is stable and completely consistent information across many countries and what everybody has to worry to reduce.