Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)
by mstefff on Tuesday June 24, 2008 @10:53AM
(#226220)
There isn't anything wrong with the wrap-around. If you're at the top of the list you shouldn't scroll up, you should be scrolling down towards the bottom.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)
by byrneseyeview on Tuesday June 24, 2008 @10:56AM
(#226225)
Have you watched someone actually use your app? Here's how it went for me: start at the top, scroll down a few days, scroll back up to the top, somehow end up scrolled back weeks. It's arbitrary to loop after a few days -- if you could collect data going back to the beginning of each company's history, that might be more sensible.
I don't see any real-world analogue to going forward from the present and ending up several weeks in the past, and having to embrace a brand-new paradigm in order to use the interface is perhaps not what you need to do to your users.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)
by mstefff on Tuesday June 24, 2008 @11:01AM
(#226236)
The list of items goes back the latest 100 items. When you are scrolling towards the bottom and you reach the end, it brings you back to the top.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)
by swombat on Tuesday June 24, 2008 @11:32AM
(#226286)
After asking your users for feedback, it's generally useful to listen to them.
Here you have a sample of users who are saying the wrap-around navigation is totally broken for them.
What's the right answer to that? Hint: it's not: "No, you're wrong, it works fine."
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)
by mstefff on Tuesday June 24, 2008 @11:35AM
(#226298)
I was just explaining the idea behind it. I'm not disagreeing. I'm removing the scrolling mechanism for the article list completely.
Really really unintuitive.
Re:Ask HN: Please review my webapp (Streetread)
by alex_c on Tuesday June 24, 2008 @11:49AM
(#226326)
User: Feature X makes it unusable for me.
Developer: There isn't anything wrong with feature X.
That is not a very healthy attitude towards feedback... good luck training users to do something they don't want. You have to account for dumb user behaviour and prevent unexpected results.