Re:Anonymous vs. HBGary: the aftermath
by CaptainZapp on Friday February 25, 2011 @07:20AM
(#2261918)
Why is it ok for HBGary to take money to compromise computers, but when Anonymous engaged in expression of speech they are targetted by federal investigators?
Or why weren't criminal charges laid against the responsibles at Sony BMG after illicitly infecting thousands of computers with malware, (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootki...), while a pimply faced teenager in Wyoming pulling such a stunt would still be rotting in jail?I'm pretty sure at any given RSA conference there are multiple folks who might personally/privately identify as members of anonymous, ie. they wouldn't need to "sneak in" to the conference b/c they are already there as legitimate members of the security community. <pure-speculation> Hell, there could be employees of HB Gary who think of themselves at anonymous. This would support your speculation that HB Gary made the sign, but complicate the motivations. </pure-speculation>
I do agree that HB Gary should be investigated as much as–if not more than–anonymous since there is some evidence of illegal or unethical business practices in the released email. I would like to think that we hold corporate security companies up to a higher standard of practice...
Anyone attending that conference could have decided to be "Anonymous". Isn't that the way the organization works?
Re:Anonymous vs. HBGary: the aftermath
by stcredzero on Friday February 25, 2011 @01:15PM
(#2263159)
Yes, the references to "V for Vendetta" aren't incidental. Many of the ideas in that graphic novel are an important component of the Anonymous ideology.
In my opinion, officers of HBGary Federal were engaged in stalking people online and selling private information about individuals for commercial purposes, as well as engaged in defaming these individuals with false information to the FBI. Given the demographic of anonymous it's quite likely that some of these individuals were children. I'm not sure if this is illegal in the US, but if they collected and prepared to sell personal information without consent about Canadian citizens they'd likely be in violation of Federal Law. (PIPEDA)
Also, regarding the millions of dollars in damages, these claims would be impossible to verify with a private company. Public companies on the other hand are required to file damages to the company both tangible and intangible. In a lot of hacking cases you'll see millions of dollars claimed, but if you look at the 10-Qs (SEC Required docs) you'll see no such filing. If you want a case to look at in particular for this, look at what happened to Kevin Mitnick. Why is it ok for HBGary to take money to compromise computers, but when Anonymous engaged in expression of speech they are targetted by federal investigators?
This is a company that used intelligence assets against pro-union websites. My personal feelings regarding unions aside, this is attempting to violate the rights of individuals to peaceably assemble. Even if it isn't illegal per se, it's highly unethical.
If HB Gary only engaged in ethical business practices there would be little damage from the disclosure of the emails. The damage results from the conspiracy to commit activities that are likely criminal.
A better question to ask is given the emails why Federal charges have not been laid against HBGary?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Labor_Relations_Act