News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Intention – DAG Todo App by toyg on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:31AM (#22604219)
Interesting. Some feedback (i only tried the webapp, from ios):

- i’d find more intuitive to have “the big prize” at the bottom, so i can work my way down by priority. Maybe an option?

- i should be able to delete the root node, which would scrap the entire hierarchy. Give us a big warning but have the feature.

- i should be able to edit nodes from the graph - even just by clicking an icon that sends me to the list-item view

- this approach is good for one-off tasks but doesn’t seem to fit recurring tasks. For example, if i want to lose weight, i have to meal-plan once every week. Either i keep adding the task manually (bleh) or i cannot deal with it here.

- maybe have a bit of song & dance when you tick off the root node.

Re:Show HN: Intention – DAG Todo App by DaveWM on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @09:37AM (#22604744)
Thanks very much for the feedback. To respond:

- Is this in the list view or the graph view? I did originally have the list order reversed (i.e. root node at the bottom), but I found it very confusing. I could potentially add a setting to control the order.

- I've tried to avoid deleting nodes where possible. If you delete a parent node, its children will be automatically re-arranged rather than deleted. Could you re-name the root node instead of deleting it?

- Agreed, the graph view is very basic at the moment. I'm looking to make it much more powerful in future.

- I've intentionally ignored recurring tasks for now, because I want to get them right when I do implement them. I'm aware it'd be a nice feature, so I am looking to add it asap.

- Good idea

Re:Show HN: Intention – DAG Todo App by toyg on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:12AM (#22605604)
1 - graph view. Maybe have something to flip the graph only.

2 - yeah, I grasped that you can just rename it, but it's a bit annoying because I might also have to manually delete a bunch of nodes below.