News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook, Reddit, Google, Twitter, YouTube joint statemen... by Angostura on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @05:45AM (#22603263)
> Better to have all sides without being muzzled.

And misinformation about health issues leads to deaths

Re:Facebook, Reddit, Google, Twitter, YouTube joint statemen... by buzzkillington on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @05:53AM (#22603306)
And what happens when the censors are the ones lying? This is how the virus spread so far in China in the first place.
Re:Facebook, Reddit, Google, Twitter, YouTube joint statemen... by jhanschoo on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @08:23AM (#22604174)
In a healthy democracy, there are appropriate mechanisms that hold censors accountable than the average layman, so that they do not abuse their office. For this reason they are granted a louder voice.

To be precise, social media platforms do not censor, but selectively grant certain entities a louder voice at a subsidized cost. Of course, these companies are out of the reach of the checks that the US government is laden with, and this should be managed by regulation or other form of checks.

Re:Facebook, Reddit, Google, Twitter, YouTube joint statemen... by buzzkillington on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @04:15PM (#22609817)
>In a healthy democracy, there are appropriate mechanisms that hold censors accountable than the average layman, so that they do not abuse their office. For this reason they are granted a louder voice.

The majority of the world does not live under healthy democracies. That the west is copying this failed model is concerning.

Re:Facebook, Reddit, Google, Twitter, YouTube joint statemen... by jhanschoo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @02:39AM (#22614206)
This counterargument isn't fatal to my point, though I tailored it to the parent comment (re: censors). There are people who can be more easily held accountable for their words, and people for whom it is difficult, or inappropriate, to punish for spouting false information. The responsible broadcaster amplifies the words of people that can be held accountable, and amplifies voices of people that cannot be held accountable only cautiously, and inside certain framed mindset (e.g. reported speech, call out lies, provide a contrasting perspective by a person who can be more easily be held accountable).

With respect to social media, it is clear that it is inappropriate and impossible to hold most laypeople accountable for spreading false information, and so it is responsible broadcasting to only amplify these voices to a limited extent.

I think that it is clear to you that I don't support unconditional free broadcast of factual claims in the Internet age, but one where one's reach must be matched by how much they have staked on the correctness of their information, proportional to the severity of the issue they are weighing in on.

Re:Facebook, Reddit, Google, Twitter, YouTube joint statemen... by buzzkillington on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @03:24AM (#22614391)
I would welcome us holding the gatekeepers to higher standards.

The only people in the media fired for the debacle of the Iraq war were the ones who called the lies of the government out.

When we let everyone speak at least the average of all the lies is closer to the truth than when we let only one lie through.

Re:Facebook, Reddit, Google, Twitter, YouTube joint statemen... by techntoke on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @05:56AM (#22603333)
Probably over 50% of movies glamorizes dangerous drug usage, affairs, violence, etc. Same with video games. Does that mean they should be held responsible when someone does something and says, well I thought that was normal because I heard/saw it there?