News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by timw4mail on Monday March 16, 2020 @08:47PM (#22600195)
I don't see how a universal basic income could be sustainable in any way.

You either have debt hyperinflation, or you have taxes high enough that the universal basic income is meaningless.

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by RedneckBob on Monday March 16, 2020 @08:57PM (#22600272)
"you have taxes high enough that the universal basic income is meaningless."

Not true. You should read the UBI policy proposal that Yang created for his POTUS run. You can find them here:

- https://www.yang2020.com/what-is-freedom-dividend-faq/ - https://www.yang2020.com/policies/the-freedom-dividend/

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by wenc on Monday March 16, 2020 @09:07PM (#22600351)
This article [1] is one of the few to have taken Andrew Yang's UBI policies seriously and on their merits (unlike most others that summarily dismiss them), thought through some of their implications, found shortcomings, but still ended up still largely acknowledging that they could work.

I think a well-designed UBI could work. The tricky part is that UBI is one of those experiments that has to be done on the large, and pulling back if it doesn't work out is challenging. Any errors in implementation and design are potentially very expensive.

[1] https://theweek.com/articles/858097/andrew-yangs-ubi-problem

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by bumby on Monday March 16, 2020 @08:55PM (#22600258)
I think some are advocating for a value added tax with certain categorical exemptions. My limited understanding is this would make necessity purchases more secure while making discretionary “luxury” purchases more expensive
Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by paulmd on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @02:25AM (#22602288)
VAT is kind of a bad tax scheme. It's regressive and discourages consumption (which, like it or not, is the engine that drives our economy).

It's better just to have income and wealth taxes.

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by jnordwick on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @04:21AM (#22602836)
> which, like it or not, is the engine that drives our economy

no it doesnt. the US consumes a lot, but you are mistaking an accounting identity with something causal. if people decided to consume less, that means they are putting off current consumption for future consumption and saving those resources for investment to allow that to happen. don't worry - they'll consume at some point when they feel it is in their best interest (and if they don't, they basically just gave us a bunch of free labor).

all economies everywhere are driven by production. human desire is pretty much endless - you rarely have to incentive consumption. when people have the resource (ie, they produced), they will naturally consume.

the only way that long term standards of living improve is by increasing productivity (this is something virtually every economist agrees to). that is done by increasing capital stocks, machinery, technology. those are all production oriented activity.

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by bumby on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @07:03AM (#22603692)
Isn’t the point of the categorical exemptions to avoid it being regressive? I.e., it skews the tax toward those consuming non-essentials?

I agree that it may discourage consumption. It’s not clear to me that this is fundamentally a bad thing, at least in terms of conspicuous consumerism

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by danaris on Monday March 16, 2020 @09:56PM (#22600672)
It's easy to structure taxes such that the UBI is extremely meaningful—it helps the people at the low end a lot, the people in the middle a little, and the people at the upper end end up paying more. But guess what? They weren't using that money anyway (except to make more money for themselves).
Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by strken on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @01:54AM (#22602129)
The people at the top don't have much money (as a percentage of their holdings), they have "wealth", where wealth means productive enterprises like e.g. toilet paper factories. The people at the bottom work in toilet paper factories and are given money which they use to buy toilet paper from the people at the top, and thus there is a productive equilibrium between the wiping masses and the owner of the means of wiping.

When the people at the top make less money, they invest less money into new toilet paper R&D and new factories. When the people at the bottom make less money, they spend less on toilet paper, and the people at the top make less money. The balance is fragile, and if your end goal is that your citizens have access to the finest and most luxurious bathroom experience they can, then you must take care to balance the engine of capital with great precision.

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by danaris on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @11:29AM (#22605787)
> When the people at the top make less money, they invest less money into new toilet paper R&D and new factories.

This (and its inverse, "when the people at the top make more money, they invest it so it does good for the whole economy") is the foundation of trickle-down economics.

It's been empirically proven not to work over the past 40 years.

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by strken on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @12:32PM (#22606679)
No, trickle-down economics is the idea that you should reduce taxes on the people at the top because they'll invest more, which only works if the balance is skewed too far towards the people at the bottom, which is clearly wrong right now.

If you had a dial labelled "wealth redistribution percentage", trickle-down economics says you that if you move it towards "0%" everything will get better. What I am saying is that if you start moving it towards "100%", everything will get better, but if you keep moving it for a long time, everything will get worse again. It is not clear to me that this has been empirically proven to be false.

Re:What If Andrew Yang Was Right? by akvadrako on Tuesday March 17, 2020 @04:03AM (#22602749)
There are lots of different plans: https://ubicalculator.com/

But the main point is 99% of people are already spending more than $1000 a month to survive, so we can afford it without spending more. It's just about how the books are balanced.

For high earners it means $1000+ in taxes. For the poorest it replaces conditional welfare.