News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canonical to take 75% of Banshee Amazon Sales by joe_the_user on Thursday February 24, 2011 @04:48PM (#2259982)
I agree Canonical's behavior doesn't seem out-of-line.

The difference between this and Apple's App store policy is that anyone create an alternative and anyone can load an alternative once they get distribution.

The comment section certainly gave me pause - it seems someone has a lot of bad feelings towards Ubuntu.

As I understand, Red Hat is larger, profitable business that has paid for a lot Gnome development (Wikipedia say Red Hat: 87.25 million net income, 3,200 employees, Canonical: $30 million net income, 350+ employees, pretty exactly one tenth the side of Red Hat).

Great but somehow the integration effort put into Canonical's distribution creates a considerably more usable system that has a good deal more traction. If, hypothetically, Canonical is "leaching", then it should really, really easy to put together a superior distribution to Ubuntu. Somehow no one has done that.

Re:Canonical to take 75% of Banshee Amazon Sales by darklajid on Thursday February 24, 2011 @06:58PM (#2260393)
The packaging for most mono based packages are community driven. I bet that they didn't pay a dime to get a readily packaged software. There's no integration effort (except for maybe their 'branding' efforts, see their tries to differentiate in some places of the desktop, e.g. the notification area). None at all.

Comparing Apple (asking for a share of the profit! people make on their platform) with a company picking a product that donates to a non-profit foundation and changing the rules (for that product, btw. We're talking about a single decision, for a single product. No 'It's always been part of the terms of use' discussion, no 'It's the same for everyone' treatment) is kinda sad.

There's no AppStore(tm) here. Apple's not even remotely connected to this change.