It is far more likely that these measures are being taken because they have been proven effective to prevent harm to citizens, than as a conspiracy to destroy small businesses.
This disease is both very infectious and relatively very deadly. We know that the death rate can double or triple if emergency health care is not available. We also know that without dramatic quarantining measures, the number of people requiring emergency care will overwhelm our health care capacity.
I am a San Francisco resident, and I am grateful that my local government is taking action. I agree with Mayor Breed's assessment that the federal government's response is terrible.
Measures are being taken, and the Japanese government believes that the rate of infection is still very much growing [1]. Schools have been shut down in Japan. And while the government is not actively enforcing quarantining, that may be due to bureaucratic roadblocks. [2]
[1] https://english.kyodonews.net/news/2020/03/8aafa8e3636c-loca...
[2] https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2020/03/11/national/politi...
They also have had the best results of any country to date.
Digging into it, they also had an incredible testing network, which is claimed to be a key differentiator. In the US, the government is actively telling people not to get tested on their own judgements.
I too would prefer much better visibility over a shelter in place order. Unfortunately, we have next to no visibility. So lacking that, I would prefer dramatic measures.
It's sort of like when South Carolina became the last state to get rid of a law requiring all cocktails to be poured out of mini liquor bottles. There was much pearl-grasping about "what if the bars rip off their customers," and "what if bars pour too much alcohol and road DUI deaths shoot way up?"
When, instead of coming with implausible or unlikely theories, you could just look at what is happening in other places and act accordingly.
More and more I’m beginning to feel like these measures are being done to destroy small businesses while the local governments know they can simply beg for money from federal after the smoke clears.
The timing and severity of these measures seems all too convenient in light of the huge money grab federal bill moving through the senate at this point.