So... it does not have healthcare for the poor? That's not good healthcare, is it?
> We cannot allow people to think that shitty but cheap and freely available healthcare somehow qualifies as a nation with “good healthcare”.
For some people, it is a choice between shitty healthcare, vs no healthcare.
Sure it does, it has either Medicaid (almost zero out of pocket) or heavily subsidized (up to 100%) marketplace plans.
In many socialised healthcare countries, tourists will get treated for free or cheaply (although you should always have insurance: and you really really want to avoid many facilities in poor countries because they often lack funds to give decent care).
There is a lot of confused thinking on this topic.
It has both. We pay a lot and get less for it on average than other nations. It's done a few things better, like allowing newer cancer treatments, but that's an exception.
Like in the extreme if you need a certain drug or procedure to survive you will pay whatever you can. You're basically held hostage. Like take a look the costs for the latest hepatitis C treatments. It's basically extortion in my opinion.
If you are well-to-do, you have a lot more options in the US than other countries, which tend to subsidize the lower end with the higher end.
To a sick person, it doesn't matter if they can't get themselves treated because the infrastructure doesn't exist or because the infrastructure exists but is out of their reach; they're dead either way in the long run.
That's precisely the worry here! If we don't keep COVID-19 spread low enough to stay within hospital capacity, no amount of money will be able to buy you treatment. Non-critical surgeries are already being postponed everywhere, even surgeries for earlier-stage cancers [1] – no matter how much you're willing to pay. Granted, not the normal case, but I'd consider ability to respond to pandemics part of the quality of a nation's healthcare system.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/14/us/coronavirus-covid-surg...
Yea if you have coronavirus it may be hard to get treatment specifically for that but if you break an arm or crack a skull you can still go in for an X-Ray and cast.
I am certain that healtcare costs factor in to ranking. Being overly expensive makes it bad.
How about changing the measure of “no amount of money” because there will always be some amount of money sufficient to get you the healthcare you need — in some cases that will mean flying you out to a different country, in others it means flying a medical team and equipment to you.
When a simple drug like insulin costs $1000/vial versus the $10 everywhere else, and simply setting a broken leg can set you back $30k where everywhere else that procedure costs $300, it’s clear that there are certain levels of “having money” that are insufficient to afford health care. There’s a huge problem of accessibility hidden behind employer provided health insurance.
- Free and good (Scandinavia, France, and many other EU countries)
- Cheap and good (South Korea)
- Expensive and good (US)
- Expensive and bad
The US doesn't rank that high out of those options to be honest.
EDIT: Actually, I think it makes sense to make a distinction between healthcare system and hospital. The US has a very poor healthcare system, while it might have good hospitals.
A true poor healthcare nation would be somewhere where no amount of money could buy you any effective treatment.
We cannot allow people to think that shitty but cheap and freely available healthcare somehow qualifies as a nation with “good healthcare”.